Unit problem in differential equation

In summary, the conversation discusses a differential equation with a constant c that has a unit of 1/ns. When solving for N, the unit of t will be in ns. There is a suggestion to non-dimensionalize the equation by defining N=N_d\bar{N}, t=t_d\bar{t}, and c=c_d\bar{c}. This results in a nondimensionalized equation with a term of c_dt_d/N_d. It is also suggested to define \tau=ct to eliminate the unit of time in the equation. The conversation ends with a clarification that t should be multiplied by c instead of divided by it.
  • #1
sunipa.som
10
0
I have one differential equation like
dN/dt=c*(other terms with no unit)
unit of c is 1/ns. Now if I solve this equation, I will get value of N corresponding to t.
(1) Then what will be the unit of t?
(2) and if I calculate dN/dt1=(other terms with no unit). where t1=t/c.
Then what will be the unit of t1?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
As I see it you have three possible units [N], [t] and [c], and I nonlimensionalise according to [itex]N=N_{d}\bar{N}[/itex], [itex]t=t_{d}\bar{t}[/itex] and [itex]c=c_{d}\bar{c}[/itex]. There I put all the dimensions into the quantities with subscript d. So this turns the differential equation into:
[tex]
\frac{d\bar{N}}{d\bar{t}}=\frac{c_{d}t_{d}}{N_{d}}\bar{c}
[/tex]
Where [itex]c_{d}t_{d}/N_{d}[/itex] is a nondimensional quantity. Does this clear things up?
 
  • #3
t will be in ns. Your RHS has dimensions of time-1. dN/dt also has dimensions of time-1. So everything matches.

Are you sure you want to divide t by c? Maybe I'm confused, but I think it would make more sense to multiply t by c, in order to get a dimensionless version of the equation. For instance, if you define [itex]\tau=ct[/itex], then you get [itex]\frac{dN}{d\tau}=\mbox{(other terms)}[/itex] and c has gone away.
 
  • #4
pmsrw3 said:
t will be in ns. Your RHS has dimensions of time-1. dN/dt also has dimensions of time-1. So everything matches.

Are you sure you want to divide t by c? Maybe I'm confused, but I think it would make more sense to multiply t by c, in order to get a dimensionless version of the equation. For instance, if you define [itex]\tau=ct[/itex], then you get [itex]\frac{dN}{d\tau}=\mbox{(other terms)}[/itex] and c has gone away.
--------------------------
Thank you. Sorry for mistake. I have to multiply t by c. Then I will get value of N for different times but then time has no unit.
 
  • #5


(1) The unit of t will depend on the units of the other terms in the differential equation. If all other terms have no units, then the unit of t will be in seconds (s). This is because c has units of 1/ns, meaning it is a rate per second. Therefore, when we solve for N, we are solving for a quantity at a specific time (t), which is measured in seconds.

(2) If we calculate dN/dt1, where t1 = t/c, then the unit of t1 will also be in seconds (s). This is because t1 is simply a scaled version of t, and the units of c (1/ns) will cancel out with the units of 1/t in the differential equation. Therefore, t1 will still be measured in seconds.
 

FAQ: Unit problem in differential equation

What is a unit problem in differential equations?

A unit problem in differential equations refers to the issue of units being inconsistent or incorrect in the equations being studied. In order for a differential equation to be solved accurately, all units must be consistent and correct.

Why is it important to address unit problems in differential equations?

Unit problems can lead to incorrect solutions and can make it difficult to interpret the results of a differential equation. It is important to address unit problems in order to ensure the accuracy and validity of the solutions.

How can unit problems be identified in a differential equation?

Unit problems can be identified by carefully checking all units present in the equation and making sure they are consistent with each other. This can also be done by converting all units to a common system, such as SI units, and checking for any discrepancies.

What are some common causes of unit problems in differential equations?

Unit problems can occur due to human error, such as using incorrect conversion factors or forgetting to convert units. They can also arise from using different unit systems in different parts of the equation, or from using non-standard or inconsistent units.

How can unit problems be resolved in differential equations?

The best way to resolve unit problems is to carefully check all units in the equation and make any necessary corrections. It is also helpful to use a consistent unit system throughout the entire equation. Additionally, double-checking the final solution for units can help identify and correct any remaining unit problems.

Similar threads

Replies
25
Views
3K
Replies
52
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top