Volume of cathedral dome (Using volumes of revolution, disk method)

In summary: No, that isn't correct. You don't start with the area of the base. You want the area of the upper hexagon in the picture, which will depend on h. h is the distance from the base to the plane of that hexagon, in other words the variable distance between the two red dots.
  • #1
insane0hflex
7
0

Homework Statement



A cathedral dome is designed with three semi circular supports of radius r so that each horiontal cross section is a regular hexagon. Show that the volume of the dome is r^3 * sqrt(3)

an accompanying figure - http://imgur.com/3fSqh

Homework Equations



Vdisk=∫pi*(f(x))^2 dx
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
insane0hflex said:

Homework Statement



A cathedral dome is designed with three semi circular supports of radius r so that each horiontal cross section is a regular hexagon. Show that the volume of the dome is r^3 * sqrt(3)

an accompanying figure - http://imgur.com/3fSqh

Homework Equations



Vdisk=∫pi*(f(x))^2 dx

That dome is not a solid of revolution since the cross sections are not circles. What you need to do is figure out the area of the hexagonal cross section at height h and do the volume by integrating cross section areas for h from 0 to r.
 
  • #3
LCKurtz said:
That dome is not a solid of revolution since the cross sections are not circles. What you need to do is figure out the area of the hexagonal cross section at height h and do the volume by integrating cross section areas for h from 0 to r.

Okay, that helps a little bit. So I would derive an expression for the area of the base, then take the integral from 0 to h? (since h = r correct)?
 
  • #4
insane0hflex said:
Okay, that helps a little bit. So I would derive an expression for the area of the base, then take the integral from 0 to h? (since h = r correct)?

No, that isn't correct. You don't start with the area of the base. You want the area of the upper hexagon in the picture, which will depend on h. h is the distance from the base to the plane of that hexagon, in other words the variable distance between the two red dots.
 

FAQ: Volume of cathedral dome (Using volumes of revolution, disk method)

What is the formula for calculating the volume of a cathedral dome using the volumes of revolution, disk method?

The formula for calculating the volume of a cathedral dome using the volumes of revolution, disk method is V = π∫ba(f(x))2dx, where a and b are the limits of the base of the dome and f(x) is the equation of the curve used to create the dome.

What assumptions are made when using the volumes of revolution, disk method to calculate the volume of a cathedral dome?

Some of the assumptions made when using the volumes of revolution, disk method to calculate the volume of a cathedral dome include: the base of the dome is circular, the dome is symmetrical, and the dome is created by rotating a curve around a central axis.

How does the height of the dome affect the calculated volume using the volumes of revolution, disk method?

The height of the dome does not affect the calculated volume using the volumes of revolution, disk method. This is because the method only considers the shape of the base and does not take into account the height of the dome.

What other methods can be used to calculate the volume of a cathedral dome besides the volumes of revolution, disk method?

Other methods that can be used to calculate the volume of a cathedral dome include: the shell method, the washer method, and the cross-section method. Each method may be more suitable for different dome shapes and can provide more accurate results in certain cases.

How can the volumes of revolution, disk method be applied to other structures besides cathedral domes?

The volumes of revolution, disk method can be applied to any structure that can be created by rotating a curve around a central axis. This includes structures such as towers, silos, and water tanks. The method can also be used to find the volume of objects such as vases and bottles with curved shapes.

Similar threads

Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
4K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Back
Top