What happens to the wave function if....

In summary: There are many interpretations of quantum mechanics, some of which are more popular than others. For a more in-depth look, you can try reading one of the many books on the subject, such as those by David Deutsch or John Bell.
  • #1
ExecNight
91
2
The question is;

In an experimental small universe, a photon is released from a source. It continues its path as a probabilistic wave function. if it interacted with mass, we could say the wave function collapsed and observe a particle photon hitting an object.

But what happens when the photon never hits with any mass(object) until it reaches the Schwarzschild radius of the source and can no longer transmit information to the source.

The photon never existed in our experimental universe then? A superposition that never actualized?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
ExecNight said:
what happens when the photon never hits with any mass(object) until it reaches the Schwarzschild radius of the source

If the source is a black hole, it can't emit a photon to begin with. If the source is an ordinary object like a star, it has no horizon, so "reaches the Schwarzschild radius" is meaningless. (If you calculate the Schwarzschild radius of, say, the Sun, you will find that it is much, much smaller than the actual radius of the Sun--which is just another way of saying that the Sun has no horizon.) So your scenario is meaningless and your questions about it can't be answered because they aren't well-defined to begin with.

You might want to take a step back and think about what your actual issue is, instead of trying to construct scenarios that might not be well-defined.
 
  • #3
But what happens when the photon never hits with any mass(object) until it reaches the Schwarzschild radius(observable universe) of the source and can no longer transmit information to the source.

It has not yet been confirmed by the scientific community that the Schwarzschild radius also gives the radius of the observable universe at a given universe when you take *your* observable universe's total mass. I am just rushing ahead in my head, sorry. But I doubt it was that important to dwell on.
 
  • #4
ExecNight said:
what happens when the photon never hits with any mass(object) until it reaches the Schwarzschild radius(observable universe) of the source and can no longer transmit information to the source

The term "observable universe" is better; better still would be "cosmological horizon", since that is the actual boundary between the region that can send light signals to us and the region that can't. The observable universe is the region that has sent light signals in the past that have reached us up to now, which is not the same.

The answer to your question depends on what interpretation of QM you adopt. Some interpretations say that the wave function (note that, strictly speaking, we should be using quantum field theory to model photons, in which the term "wave function" is somewhat problematic, but I'll ignore that here) is physically real, so we can use it to describe a quantum system even if it never interacts with anything else. Other interpretations say the wave function only models the probabilities of results of measurements that could be made on the system, so there is no point in even assigning a wave function to a system that never gets observed or measured. We have no way of deciding which interpretation is correct at our current state of knowledge, since they all make the same predictions for all observations.

ExecNight said:
It has not yet been confirmed by the scientific community that the Schwarzschild radius also gives the radius of the observable universe

No, it is well known in the scientific community that the universe as a whole does not have a Schwarzschild radius because it is not an isolated system surrounded by vacuum, which is the only kind of system to which the term "Schwarzschild radius" even applies. The spacetime geometry of the universe is very different, and the observable universe is not the same as a black hole horizon or a Schwarzschild radius.
 
  • #5
Can you share the name of the interpretations so that I can check them out in detail?

Cosmological horizon yes, that's the correct word. The use of the Schwarzschild radius is a bad definition like you have put. I had that problem and now consider it like a disability when I am trying to say something and use a word to define it, I assume everybody understands what I am thinking in my head. Of course, I am just trying to mean the equation instead of the definition of the term.

I have given up a few years ago and just accepted I am not good at communicating, Instead of getting frustrated and stressed lol.
 

Related to What happens to the wave function if....

What happens to the wave function if the system is in a superposition state?

If the system is in a superposition state, the wave function will exist as a combination of all the possible states that the system can be in. This means that the wave function will not collapse into a single state until it is measured.

What happens to the wave function if the system interacts with an external environment?

If the system interacts with an external environment, the wave function may change or collapse. This is known as decoherence and can be caused by various factors such as the strength of the interaction and the temperature of the environment.

What happens to the wave function if the system is measured?

If the system is measured, the wave function will collapse into one of its possible states. The specific state that the wave function collapses into is determined by the measurement process and the properties of the system.

What happens to the wave function if the system is in a bound state?

If the system is in a bound state, the wave function will describe the probability of finding the system in a certain energy state. The wave function will also have a finite amplitude within a certain range, known as the spatial extent of the bound state.

What happens to the wave function if the system is in an unbound state?

If the system is in an unbound state, the wave function will describe the probability of finding the system with a certain energy or momentum. The wave function will also have infinite amplitude, meaning that the system can exist at any position in space.

Similar threads

Replies
18
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
857
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
930
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
8
Views
2K
Back
Top