- #36
PeterDonis
Mentor
- 47,601
- 23,875
timmdeeg said:The latter however is inhomogeneous.
On small enough distance scales, yes. On large enough distance scales, homogeneity is a good approximation. That's why it's used in the models of the universe as a whole in cosmology. Those models aren't intended to apply on distance scales small enough for inhomogeneities to be significant.
timmdeeg said:Of course if we apply the average matter density (which can be seen as being homogeneous on very large scales) locally
Which we don't. Nobody models a galaxy, let alone a solar system, let alone a star or planet, by assuming it has the average matter density of the entire universe. Why would you think they would?
I'm confused about where you are getting these impressions from.
timmdeeg said:my concern is that we seem to apply at small scales what is primarily true globally
Which is an unfounded concern, because we don't; why would we, since it would make no sense?
Once again, I'm confused about where you are getting these impressions from. You seem to have some underlying assumptions that are leading you astray, but I don't know what they are.