- #1
marlon
- 3,792
- 11
I need to know how is the best singer...
(it is for a
scientific study...)
marlon
(it is for a
scientific study...)marlon
What is the Best Singer? - Very Important Study
In summary, the poll showed that people prefer Luciano Pavarotti as the best singer. He has demonstrated his vocal range and ability better than the other three. Shakira, Christina Aguilera, and Britney Spears are all good singers, but Pavarotti is the one with the best voice.
- #2
marlon
- 3,792
- 11
i will go for the big guy...mmm sexy...
O SOLE MIO
O SOLE MIO
- #3
Moonbear
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 11,924
- 54
How could you even disgrace Pavarotti by putting him in the same list as those other three?
- #4
marlon
- 3,792
- 11
Moonbear said:
Hey man ,easy, i am a hughe Pavarotti fan.
This list is made based upon psychological motivations which i cannot yet reveal but they do seem to work...
Thanks for the vote...
marlon
- #5
Moonbear
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 11,924
- 54
marlon said:Hey man ,easy, i am a hughe Pavarotti fan.
This list is made based upon psychological motivations which i cannot yet reveal but they do seem to work...
Thanks for the vote...
marlon
Sorry...should have tossed a few smilies into that post
Just weighing in my opinion - #6
humanino
- 2,527
- 8
that was priceless dude, especially when I got to see the results of the poll
By the way, moonbear is a gorgeous woman, you lost your chance by calling her "man"
- #7
Evo
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
- 24,017
- 3,338
I had to vote for Pavarotti.
I have to say that I don't even listen to the other three. My kids and their friends don't either.
I have to say that I don't even listen to the other three. My kids and their friends don't either.
Last edited:
- #8
jimmy p
Gold Member
- 399
- 67
It's a toughy because I know that Luciano Pavarotti is a really good singer, but he is in a different genre of music to the other three. And out of the other 3, I would pick Shakira because she has a damn good voice. I prefer her Spanish stuff though. Even still I'm not a fan of "pop" music... Gar! help me decide!
Last edited:
- #9
Ba
- 106
- 0
Yes I go for Pavarotti as well, 'pop' music is not for me.
- #10
Moonbear
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 11,924
- 54
Hey, who voted for Britney Spears? Come on, fess up!
JimmyP, I agree, out of the remaining three, Shakira comes out ahead...her music is just lots of fun, but pop music just doesn't show off one's voice well. Even if she has a good voice, you can't really tell. She does have a clear voice, and can actually carry a tune, unlike some pop stars, but pop music just doesn't give much opportunity to show off vocal range, which I think is important to consider when saying someone is the best singer out of a group.
Funny thing is, I'd much prefer to listen to Shakira's music than Pavarotti's, but what I like in music wasn't the question, the question is who is the better singer, and in that case, Pavarotti is the one who has demonstrated best his vocal range and ability.
JimmyP, I agree, out of the remaining three, Shakira comes out ahead...her music is just lots of fun, but pop music just doesn't show off one's voice well. Even if she has a good voice, you can't really tell. She does have a clear voice, and can actually carry a tune, unlike some pop stars, but pop music just doesn't give much opportunity to show off vocal range, which I think is important to consider when saying someone is the best singer out of a group.
Funny thing is, I'd much prefer to listen to Shakira's music than Pavarotti's, but what I like in music wasn't the question, the question is who is the better singer, and in that case, Pavarotti is the one who has demonstrated best his vocal range and ability.
- #11
Gokul43201
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 7,220
- 24
Used to be a time when there was some halfways decent Pop. Now it's all just "Vanilla Pop".
- #12
marlon
- 3,792
- 11
I prefer Luciano too, especially in La Boheme, Turandot (you know, with the gran finale : NESSUN DORMA) and Un Ballo In Maschera...
Nevertheless I do think that Christina has the best voice of the three "pop"-singers. Britney SUCKS BIG TIME...
But in the end,
Pavarotti is the one with vocal chords that were kissed by an angel.
Give it up for BIG P
regards
marlon
Nevertheless I do think that Christina has the best voice of the three "pop"-singers. Britney SUCKS BIG TIME...
But in the end,
Pavarotti is the one with vocal chords that were kissed by an angel.
Give it up for
BIG P regards
marlon
- #13
marlon
- 3,792
- 11
Oh yes and eeuuh, Moonbear
sorry for calling you a man...
regards
marlon, also a man
sorry for calling you a man...
regards
marlon, also a man
- #14
BobG
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 352
- 88
Moonbear said:
He once sang with Loretta Lynn.
Well, okay, I guess that still doesn't explain how he could be in the same list with those other three. Loretta Lynn actually has a personality.Edit: Actually, weren't Christina Aguilera and Britney Spears Mousketeers? Surely Pavarotti wasn't a mousketeer, was he?
FAQ: What is the Best Singer? - Very Important Study
What criteria are used to determine the best singer?
The criteria used to determine the best singer can vary depending on personal opinions, but some common factors include vocal range, technique, stage presence, versatility, and impact on the music industry.
Who is considered the best singer of all time?
This is a highly debated question and there is no definitive answer. Some popular choices include Freddie Mercury, Whitney Houston, and Aretha Franklin, among many others. Ultimately, the best singer is subjective and can vary based on personal preferences.
Can a computer algorithm determine the best singer?
A computer algorithm may be able to analyze and compare certain vocal elements, but it cannot fully capture the emotional and artistic components of singing. The best singer is often determined through a combination of technical skill and personal connection with the audience.
Are there any scientific studies on what makes a singer "the best"?
There have been studies on vocal techniques and their effects on singing, but determining the best singer is largely subjective and cannot be fully quantified through scientific research. However, these studies can provide insights into the technical aspects of singing and how they contribute to overall performance.
Does the genre of music affect who is considered the best singer?
Yes, the genre of music can greatly influence who is considered the best singer. Different genres require different vocal techniques and styles, so what may be considered the best singer in one genre may not be the same in another. It is important to consider the specific criteria and context when determining the best singer in a particular genre.