What Is the Role of Thought in a Predetermined Universe?

[xxxxxxxx]

if universe, everything is predetermined, then what is point for thoughts?

in block universe view, what is the point for human beings to be able to think? what thoughts can make a difference in a block universe?

 

[WannabeNewton]

so you can think about why thinking is useless

 

[micromass]

There is no point to anything. This universe is meaningless and pointless.

Anyway, I fear this is not allowed under the philosophy posting rules. So I expect a lock soon...

 

[Ryan_m_b]

Anyway, I fear this is not allowed under the philosophy posting rules. So I expect a lock soon...

You fear and expect correctly.

 

[sardar]

I approach this question from a logical and evidence-based perspective. While it is true that some theories propose the concept of a predetermined universe, it is important to note that this is still a highly debated and unproven idea. In fact, many scientists argue that the universe is not predetermined and that there is room for free will and choice.

Furthermore, even if we were to accept the idea of a predetermined universe, it does not necessarily negate the importance of thought and consciousness. Our thoughts and actions are still a crucial part of our experience and have the potential to shape our lives and the world around us. Just because something is predetermined does not mean that our thoughts and choices are meaningless.

Additionally, the concept of a block universe does not necessarily mean that all events and actions are predetermined. It simply suggests that all events, including our thoughts and actions, exist simultaneously in time. This does not discount the idea of causality or the impact of our thoughts and choices on the course of events.

In summary, the point of being able to think and have thoughts in a predetermined or block universe is still relevant and significant. Our thoughts and choices have the potential to shape our experiences and the world around us, and even in a predetermined universe, they are still an integral part of our existence.