Where do gravitational field lines originate from?

  • Thread starter chhitiz
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Lines
In summary: I think you are asking about electric field lines. magnetic field lines are circles around the charges.
  • #1
chhitiz
221
0
if we assume the existence of gravitational field lines to be true, it implies that all massive bodies are spheres with field lines converging into them from all directions. this would be true for all planets, stars, even black holes. so, where do these lines come from?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
From the bodies. This is why we say that mass is the source of gravity.
 
  • #3
but those lines converge into the bodies. what i am asking is where do they emerge from?
 
  • #4
good point. they have to end somewhere.
 
  • #5
I think you're taking the concept of field lines too literally. The lines aren't real, they're just the path a point mass would take if it were placed along a field line, neglecting the gravitational attraction the point mass would have on the matter configuration from which the field lines terminates.
 
  • #6
I think you are taking his question too literally. the lines are mathematical artifacts but they still have to end somewhere.
 
  • #7
flux lines are not just the path a particle would take. as I'm sure you know, they also encode the strength of the field at each position. they can do this because the field follows an inverse square law (in 3 dimensions).
 
  • #8
I guess if the flux lines from a planet are thought of as the slope of a scalar field then eventually they must come back together again on the opposite side of the universe.
 
  • #9
What does "opposite side of the universe" mean?
 
  • #10
as in universe=surface of hypersphere.
 
  • #11
what is a hypersphere? reminds me of the model in a book where universe was the surface of an ever expanding balloon
 
  • #12
Field lines all come from the same source, wether you are talking about gravitational, electrical, or magnetic field lines. That source is your pen (or other graphing implement).
 
  • #13
Defennder is correct. One is taking the notion of "field lines" too literally here. One should always look at the formulation. Look at Coulomb's Law, for example, for a point charge. Can you see "lines" in that formulation? Or what about surfaces? Do you imagine the equipotential surfaces when you look at Coulomb's Law? No? Then why lines? After all, in a Hamiltonian, it is the potential energy form that is of more importance than forces.

What we end up doing in trying to conceptualize the direction of the force on a test charge in such a field is to sketch out such forces (or electric field). This is simply a "scheme" to help us tackle a problem or a visualization. It has nothing to do with ANY physical "lines".

Thus, the question on where "lines" ends really needs to be clarified as how a particular field geometry can be described at a boundary, meaning that this is more of a boundary condition issue than anything else.

Zz.
 
  • #14
what i meant was, if magnetic field lines originate from a positive pole, is it possible for matter to have 'emerging' gravitational field lines?
 
  • #15
I think you mean electric field lines. magnetic field lines are circles around the charges.

there are of course no actual lines. the lines are there just to help us visualize the vector field. if gravity didnt follow an inverse square law then flux lines wouldn't work. we would have to use something else. (actually inverse square works only in 3 dimensions. in 6 dimensions you would need an inverse 5th power law).

I have no idea what you mean by 'emerging'.

flux lines will work for any field that follows an inverse square law in 3 dimensions. that includes gravity.

that assumes an infinite perfectly flat universe. what happens when the universe inst infinite or flat I don't know.
 
  • #16
If I'm not wrong he's asking where does he start drawing say a gravitational field line from the tail arrow to the head. Where do the lines emerge from? I think DaleSpam answered that question already. I don't think there's any place in the universe you could situate 2 masses without them having any gravitational attraction between them, so if you wanted to, you should start drawing at the universe's boundaries.

Unless of course there is such a thing as "negative mass" and I don't mean the semiconductor physics concept.
 

FAQ: Where do gravitational field lines originate from?

Where do the lines on a map come from?

The lines on a map are created by cartographers, who use a variety of techniques and tools to accurately represent geographic features such as coastlines, borders, and roads. These lines are based on data collected from satellite imagery, aerial photography, ground surveys, and other sources.

How are the lines on a map determined?

The determination of the lines on a map depends on the specific purpose of the map. For example, political boundaries are determined by treaties and agreements between countries, while topographic lines are determined by contour lines representing changes in elevation. Land surveying and GIS technology also play a role in the determination of map lines.

Are the lines on a map accurate?

The accuracy of map lines varies depending on the scale of the map and the data sources used. Generally, maps with larger scales (e.g. street maps) will have more accurate lines than maps with smaller scales (e.g. world maps). Additionally, maps are constantly being updated as new data becomes available, so the accuracy of map lines may change over time.

Who is responsible for creating and updating map lines?

Map lines are typically created and updated by cartographers, geographers, and surveyors who work for government agencies, private companies, or academic institutions. These professionals use specialized knowledge and tools to accurately depict geographic features on maps.

Can map lines change?

Yes, map lines can change over time due to a variety of factors. Natural events such as erosion, earthquakes, and volcanic eruptions can alter the physical features represented by map lines. Political changes, such as the creation of new borders or the renaming of places, can also result in changes to map lines. Additionally, as technology and data collection methods improve, map lines may be updated to reflect more accurate information.

Back
Top