Why can't photons reverse annihilate ?

In summary, the conversation discussed the concept of photon "reverse annihilation" and whether gamma photons can spontaneously turn into an electron-positron pair. It was explained that this process, known as pair production, can occur with high-energy gamma photons and requires two photons for conservation of momentum. However, it is much more difficult to get gamma photons to collide in a way that produces an electron-positron pair. Additionally, it was mentioned that a single photon cannot satisfy the laws of energy and momentum conservation in this process.
  • #1
Darkmisc
220
31
Why can't photons "reverse annihilate"?

If electron-positron pairs annihilate to product gamma radiation, why can't gamma photons spontaneously become a electron-positron pair?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


They can. You need two photons for conservation of momentum, but one can come from the electric field near a nucleus.

The process is called pair production.
 
  • #3


Why does another photon or nuclei have to be involved?

Can't the photon's energy and momentum be converted into the mass, kinetic energy and momentum of the electron-positron pair in free space?
 
  • #4


Darkmisc said:
If electron-positron pairs annihilate to product gamma radiation, why can't gamma photons spontaneously become a electron-positron pair?

A pair of gamma photons can produce an electron-positron pair if they have high enough energy and meet in the right way. Look up "two-photon physics" or "gamma-gamma physics" for more details.

A positron and an electron are mutually attractive so the probability of annihilation is high. It is much more difficult to get gamma photons to collide in a such a way that the center of mass energy is sufficient to produce an electron-positron pair.
 
  • #5


Darkmisc said:
Why does another photon or nuclei have to be involved?

Can't the photon's energy and momentum be converted into the mass, kinetic energy and momentum of the electron-positron pair in free space?

No, it's not possible to satisfy energy and momentum conservation laws in that case.
 
  • #6


Look at the center-of-mass system. Here you have two photons with the same energy (and therefore momentum) heading towards each other, to total momentum is zero. They convert into a particle and antiparticle pair, which head away from each other with the same speed. They have the same mass, therefore again the total momentum is zero. Momentum is conserved. Energy conservation is easy, you take the energy of the photons, subtract the rest energy of the new particles, what is left is the kinetic energy. Each new particle gets 50% of that.

With a single photon you cannot find a solution that satisfies energy and momentum conservation.

The process actually is very efficient for photons with >1.022 GeV energy. Then the second photon can have close to zero energy, which is the case for virtual photons in a static electric field. For such high-energy gamma rays, pair production is the dominant absorption mechanism.
 

FAQ: Why can't photons reverse annihilate ?

Why can't photons reverse annihilate?

Photons cannot reverse annihilate because they are elementary particles with no known substructure. This means that they are not composed of smaller particles and cannot be broken down or transformed into other particles.

Can photons ever change into other particles?

No, photons cannot change into other particles as they are the fundamental particles that make up light and electromagnetic radiation. They do not have the ability to transform or be transformed into other particles.

What is the process of photon annihilation?

Photon annihilation occurs when a photon collides with its antiparticle, such as an electron and positron. The two particles annihilate each other, releasing energy in the form of two new photons with opposite directions and equal energy.

Can the annihilation process be reversed?

No, the annihilation process cannot be reversed. Once a photon has been annihilated, it cannot be recreated or brought back to its original state. This is due to the laws of conservation of energy and momentum.

Are there any exceptions to photon annihilation?

There are some rare instances where photons can interact and produce other particles, such as in high-energy collisions. However, these interactions do not involve the reverse annihilation of photons, as the original photons are still destroyed in the process.

Similar threads

Replies
48
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
533
Replies
4
Views
896
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
981
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top