Why Does HCN Kill and Not KCN?

  • Thread starter justwild
  • Start date
In summary: HCN is protonated in 99% (or - in other words - 99% of the cyanide is in the HCN form). Note that that means cyanides in the blood stream are transported mainly in this form, not as CN-.
  • #1
justwild
53
0
Why HCN not KCN kills?

I have read in wikipedia's article for Potassium cyanide and in there it is written that
"
The lethal dose for potassium cyanide is 200-300 mg.[6] The toxicity of potassium cyanide when ingested depends on the acidity of the stomach, because it must react with an acid to become hydrogen cyanide, the deadly form of cyanide. Grigori Rasputin may have survived a potassium cyanide poisoning because his stomach acidity was unusually low.[7]
". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potassium_cyanide
My question is Why HCN not KCN kills? Untill now it had been known to me that it is cyanide ion which kills...
 
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2


Don't believe in everything you find in wikipedia. No idea what is the real mechanism of the cyanide poisoning, but whoever wrote the wikipedia article was wrong. At blood pH most of the cyaninde (around 99%) is already protonated. In stomach pH is much lower, so amount of protonated cyanide is even higher.

Besides, if the pH in Rasputin stomach was "unusually low" it would mean amount of protonated cyanide would be higher, not lower.
 
  • #3


why acidic medium be there for protonation?
 
  • #4


justwild said:
why acidic medium be there for protonation?

Where "there"?
 
  • #5


Partly memory, have not info to hand, but certainly the mechanism of cyanide poisoning is that cyanide forms a practically irreversible bond with the terminal oxidising catalyst ('electron acceptor') in the cell called cytochrome a3. That is, oxygen via this catalyst oxidises other cytochromes and things which in a chain of one thing oxidising another oxidise glucose etc. and give us or energy. The cytochromes contain iron-heme groups similar to those in haemoglobin, and it is alternately reduced by cellular electron donors and oxidised by oxygen . The cyanide forms a bond with the iron, I presume the >Fe3+< . It is CN- that reacts. (It may be a minority of total cyanide but it is in rapid equilibrium with the HCN and reacts rapidly and irreversibly.)

So the effect is that it shuts down practically all the metabolism of the cell.
 
Last edited:
  • #6


epenguin said:
Partly memory, have not info to hand, but certainly the mechanism of cyanide poisoning is that cyanide forms a practically irreversible bond with the terminal oxidising catalyst ('electron acceptor') in the cell called cytochrome a3. That is, oxygen via this catalyst oxidises other cytochromes and things which in a chain of one thing oxidising another oxidise glucose etc. and give us or energy. The cytochromes contain iron-heme groups similar to those in haemoglobin, and it is alternately reduced by cellular electron donors and oxidised by oxygen . The cyanide forms a bond with the iron, I presume the >Fe3+< . It is CN- that reacts. (It may be a minority of total cyanide but it is in rapid equilibrium with the HCN and reacts rapidly and irreversibly.)

So the effect is that it shuts down practically all the metabolism of the cell.
I am not sure why the moderators aren't posting my reply. Maybe speculating about Rasputin is against Forum policy. So here goes a shorter reply.
HCN is less topic than KCN in the stomach because HCN is a gas. The stomach isn't made to absorb gas. However, a salt like KCN is easily absorbed.
If Mr. R had an acid stomach that day because of something that he ate, the KCN could have turned into HCN. Then, the HCN would have been dissipated before his blood stream could absorb it.
I am not saying that I believe that theory. I was just discussing the chemistry of that hypothesis.
 
  • #7


Darwin123 said:
If Mr. R had an acid stomach that day because of something that he ate, the KCN could have turned into HCN. Then, the HCN would have been dissipated before his blood stream could absorb it.

Sorry, but this is a nonsense that I have already addressed in the very first answer in the thread.

pKa of HCN is around 9.3. That means already at pH 7.3 - which is more or less pH of the blood - CN- is protonated in 99% (or - in other words - 99% of the cyanide is in the HCN form). Note that that means cyanides in the blood stream are transported mainly in this form, not as CN-.

pH in stomach is much lower than that - around 2. That means 99.99999% protonation. You can't get substantially higher than that because of the low stomach pH.

In short: we can safely assume in the stomach ALL cyanide is protonated, regardless of whether someone has an acid stomach or not. This is a high school chemistry.
 
  • #8


Borek said:
Sorry, but this is a nonsense that I have already addressed in the very first answer in the thread.

pKa of HCN is around 9.3. That means already at pH 7.3 - which is more or less pH of the blood - CN- is protonated in 99% (or - in other words - 99% of the cyanide is in the HCN form). Note that that means cyanides in the blood stream are transported mainly in this form, not as CN-.

pH in stomach is much lower than that - around 2. That means 99.99999% protonation. You can't get substantially higher than that because of the low stomach pH.

In short: we can safely assume in the stomach ALL cyanide is protonated, regardless of whether someone has an acid stomach or not. This is a high school chemistry.
Thank you. I didn't think to look up the pKa of HCN. In my defense, the article in that link the OP quoted didn't bother to look it up, either. The link says that the acidity would effect the chemical species of the cyanide, and according to this "high school" analysis this couldn't be true.
I think that answers the OP's question. The pH of the stomach couldn't affect the absorption of cyanide, one way or the other. Therefore, that Wikipedia article and the speculation behind it is wrong.
 

FAQ: Why Does HCN Kill and Not KCN?

Why is HCN more toxic than KCN?

HCN (hydrogen cyanide) is more toxic than KCN (potassium cyanide) because it is a smaller molecule and can more easily penetrate cell membranes. It also has a higher affinity for binding to enzymes in the body, which disrupts their normal function and leads to cell death.

How does HCN kill?

HCN kills by inhibiting cellular respiration, which is the process by which cells produce energy. It does this by binding to cytochrome c oxidase, an enzyme involved in the electron transport chain. This prevents the cells from using oxygen and leads to cellular death.

Can HCN and KCN be used as poisons?

Yes, both HCN and KCN can be used as poisons. However, HCN is more commonly used due to its higher toxicity and ease of access. KCN is often used in industrial settings, such as gold mining, but can also be used as a poison.

Is there an antidote for HCN and KCN poisoning?

Yes, there are antidotes for both HCN and KCN poisoning. The most common antidote for HCN is sodium thiosulfate, which acts by converting HCN into a less toxic compound. For KCN poisoning, the antidote is usually a combination of sodium nitrite and sodium thiosulfate, which work together to detoxify the cyanide.

Can HCN and KCN be found in nature?

Yes, both HCN and KCN can be found in nature. HCN is produced naturally by certain plants, such as apple seeds and cassava, as a defense mechanism against herbivores. KCN can also be found in plants, as well as in some bacteria and fungi. It is also used in small amounts by the human body for various metabolic processes.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
4K
Replies
78
Views
10K
Back
Top