Why doesn't Gaus's law count for charges outside the area?

In summary, Gauss's law still works for calculating electric field when there are charges outside because the net contribution from those outside charges is 0. This is because the flux going into the surface from any outside charge also exits the surface, and Gauss's law takes into account the net flux through the surface. Therefore, only the charges enclosed within the closed surface are considered in the equation, which requires a surface integral.
  • #1
Jae
10
0
In Gaus's law when the integral is set up, we don't account for the charge outside the closed area. Why is this? How does this law work when the charges outside are not accounted for and only the charges enclosed is in the equation? I need an explanation why Gaus's law still works for calculating electric field when there are charges outside. This has been confusing me.

Thank you for your time.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The flux going into the surface from any outside charge necessarily exits the surface. Since Gauss's law takes into account the net flux through the surface, we can add up the individual contributions, and the net contribution from the outside charges will be 0.
 
  • #3
It may help to think about this in terms of flux. Imagine you have a single positive charge inside a closed surface. Its field lines extend radially and pass through the surface, so the flux is related to the charge inside. Field lines of a charge outside the surface do not contribute to the flux because its field lines go through one side and out the other, the surface isn't a closed surface for it. The left side of Gauss's law IS the equation for flux and therefore only pertains to charges within the closed surface, which is why it requires a surface integral.
 

FAQ: Why doesn't Gaus's law count for charges outside the area?

1. Why doesn't Gauss's law apply to charges outside the area?

The reason Gauss's law does not apply to charges outside the area is because Gauss's law is based on the concept of symmetry. It assumes that the electric field lines are equally distributed in all directions around a charge. However, this is not always the case when considering charges outside the area.

2. Can Gauss's law be applied to charges outside the area?

In some cases, Gauss's law can be applied to charges outside the area. This is known as the "Gauss's law for enclosed charges" and involves calculating the electric field at a point outside the area by considering the charges enclosed within a surface surrounding that point.

3. What happens if I try to apply Gauss's law to charges outside the area?

If Gauss's law is applied to charges outside the area without considering the enclosed charges, it will not give an accurate result. This is because the electric field lines may not be symmetrical around the charge and the flux through the surface will not be equal to the enclosed charge.

4. Are there any exceptions to Gauss's law not applying to charges outside the area?

There are some special cases where Gauss's law can be applied to charges outside the area. For example, if the charges outside the area are distributed in a symmetrical pattern, then Gauss's law can be used to calculate the electric field at a point outside the area.

5. How do we calculate the electric field at a point outside the area?

To calculate the electric field at a point outside the area, we can use the principle of superposition. This involves taking into account the contributions of all the charges outside the area and the charges enclosed within a surface surrounding the point of interest. The resulting electric field will be the sum of the individual electric fields due to each charge.

Similar threads

Replies
83
Views
4K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
435
Replies
24
Views
6K
Replies
30
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
10K
Back
Top