Why is there a hierarchy of Super Mentors?

  • Thread starter arildno
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation revolved around the exclusion of two esteemed Super Mentors from the "Super Mentors list" in the "View Forum Leaders" thread and the potential negative effects of this exclusion on their self-confidence. The conversation then shifted to discussing the possibility of creating a new forum for grad students and making Moonbear the moderator, as well as the original purpose of the academic and career guidance forum for grad students to exchange ideas.
  • #1
arildno
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
10,123
138
I find it very distressing that our esteemed Super Mentors Moonbear and vanesch have been ignored to the point that their names isn't even displayed
in the "Super Mentors list" in the "View Forum Leaders" thread.

This type of subtle power games can be very corrosive on the affected individuals' self-confidences to the point that they cannot supermentoring anymore! :cry:

I urge the powers that be that they should look kindly upon our newest Super Mentors and enroll them into those lists they are entitled to being enrolled in.

EDIT:
Oh dear, I just saw that they have just been enrolled in that list, Sorry..:blushing:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Your suckuping skills are beyond supreme :biggrin:

Oh and probably because they weren't added as Moderators of any of the forums? Like Monique and someone else is a mod for Biology.. I donno maybe 2 mods per forum is max?

I say we nominate Moonbear to be a mod for Brain Teasers :-p
 
Last edited:
  • #3
cronxeh said:
Your suckuping skills are beyond supreme :biggrin:
That's okay, I don't mind. :smile:

Oh and probably because they weren't added as Moderators of any of the forums? Like Monique and someone else is a mod for Biology.. I donno maybe 2 mods per forum is max?
We're still in training (at least that's what the other mentors tell us when they hand us the mop and bucket and send us to clean the executive restroom :rolleyes:).

I say we nominate Moonbear to be a mod for Brain Teasers :-p
Do you really hate me that much? :frown:
 
  • #4
Well, to answer to OP's question, http://www.sitepoint.com/article/super-moderator-guide" is why, written by Bernhardt himself I might add.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5
cronxeh said:
Your suckuping skills are beyond supreme
Well, I cannot lie and assert that I am wholly "unskilled", but it was a sincere and heart-felt appeal from my part, since we cannot live with Super Mentors who have been trodden down by scorn, ridicule and held enchained by inferiority complexes.

It was, simply put, a matter of civic duty for me to speak out.


I say we nominate Moonbear to be a mod for Brain Teasers :-p
Good idea!
Perhaps vanesch will Super Mentor the TD Archives? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
  • #6
Moonbear said:
Do you really hate me that much? :frown:
Oh, perhaps not the Brain Teasers, then.
What about..GD?
 
  • #7
ohhh MOD's in training , sounds so cool! Study hard Moonbear, make us proud!
 
  • #8
Moonbear said:
Do you really hate me that much? :frown:

:smile:

Are you insane? Why, I'd never! Actually come to think about it I think there would be a good idea to start a new forum about Grad Student Life and make Moony the mod for that :biggrin: I think something along lines of http://www.phdcomics.com/proceedings/ Piled Higher and Deeper forum, but in a bit more advanced setting such as PF :biggrin:

No but seriously there are a lot of grad students around here and I'm sure an exchange of research related ideas and suggestions would be refreshing
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #9
Mk said:
Well, to answer to OP's question, http://www.sitepoint.com/article/super-moderator-guide" is why, written by Bernhardt himself I might add.
You mean I didn't have to buy Greg that new car? :confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #10
cronxeh said:
:smile:

Are you insane? Why, I'd never!


Actually come to think about it I think there would be a good idea to start a new forum about Grad Student Life and make Moony the mod for that :biggrin: I think something along lines of http://www.phdcomics.com/proceedings/ Piled Higher and Deeper forum, but in a bit more advanced setting such as PF :biggrin:

No but seriously there are a lot of grad students around here and I'm sure an exchange of research related ideas and suggestions would be refreshing

This is a great idea. I really like it. And I love piled higher and deeper... it is too true.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #11
cronxeh said:
No but seriously there are a lot of grad students around here and I'm sure an exchange of research related ideas and suggestions would be refreshing
What do you think the rest of this forum is supposed to be used for? You know, all that stuff up top. :biggrin: And, actually, back when we first started the academic and career guidance forum, I envisioned it being a place for grad students to swap ideas too, not just for the undergrads to ask what physics class to take. I thought it might be a place where folks could ask for teaching advice for their first solo course, or discuss ideas for innovative ways to present tough concepts to a class, or ideas on how to deal with a bad mentor, etc. There's no reason at all that grad students and post-docs can't ask their questions there too (it might even help the undergrads see what they are getting themselves into as they're thinking of applying to grad school so they can make a more informed decision if they have the sort of dedication it really takes).
 

FAQ: Why is there a hierarchy of Super Mentors?

Why is there a hierarchy of Super Mentors?

The hierarchy of Super Mentors exists for several reasons. Firstly, it allows for a clear structure and organization within the mentorship program. This helps mentees understand who they can turn to for guidance and support. Additionally, a hierarchy can also provide opportunities for mentorship growth and development, as mentees can eventually become mentors themselves.

How is the hierarchy of Super Mentors determined?

The hierarchy of Super Mentors is typically determined based on experience, expertise, and seniority within the mentorship program. Those with more experience and knowledge are often placed in higher positions within the hierarchy, as they can provide more guidance and support to mentees.

Is the hierarchy of Super Mentors necessary?

The hierarchy of Super Mentors is not always necessary, as some mentorship programs may function without a formal hierarchy. However, it can be beneficial for larger programs or those with a high number of mentees, as it provides structure and helps ensure that mentees receive appropriate support and guidance.

How does the hierarchy of Super Mentors impact the mentorship relationship?

The hierarchy of Super Mentors can have both positive and negative impacts on the mentorship relationship. On one hand, it can provide clear roles and responsibilities for both mentors and mentees, which can help foster a successful relationship. On the other hand, it may create a power dynamic that can be intimidating for mentees and hinder open communication.

Can the hierarchy of Super Mentors change or evolve?

Yes, the hierarchy of Super Mentors is not set in stone and can change or evolve over time. As mentees gain experience and knowledge, they can move up in the hierarchy and become mentors themselves. Additionally, the structure of the hierarchy can also be adjusted or adapted as needed to best meet the needs of the mentorship program.

Similar threads

Engineering Physics dropout software engineer looking for guidance
Replies
8
Views
3K
Current and Future AI Threats to Humanity and the Human Response
Replies
10
Views
3K
Requesting suggestions for languages, libraries, and architectures for parallel (and sometimes non parallel) numerical and scientific computations
Replies
8
Views
3K
Stop Spoiling Your Kids: The Dangers of Instant Gratification
Replies
10
Views
3K
BRS: PKI Cryptosystems for SA/Ms: A Tutorial
Replies
13
Views
3K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top