Why isn't the world flat ? (Are you sure )

  • Thread starter Langbein
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Flat
In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of the shape of the Earth and how it is perceived by different individuals. The speaker questions why the dominant perception is that the Earth is round, when in their everyday experience it appears flat. They suggest that there are multiple ways to see the Earth, including roundness, flatness, and emptiness. The speaker also mentions the idea of local flatness in a globally curved space and states that the Earth is a two-sphere but appears flat locally. The conversation ends with the suggestion to seek education rather than philosophical discussion on the topic.
  • #1
Langbein
209
0
One thing I think is a little bit funny (among a lot of other things).

All the time I have learned and heard that the world is round, and when I travel with aircraft I can actually se it is at last courved. But when planning long distance travels I understand that it is quite round as it is possible to travel arount it.

But as I observe the Earth most of the time it is completely flat.

I don't live on a ball, I don't walk on a ball, I'm not sleeping or working on a ball, it is completely flat, as observed by me. As I have learned to know the Earth it is completely flat all the time.

I understand this - that if I were a astronaut the "roundness" of the Earth would be something important. Even if I were a pilot on a jet airplane "roundness" might be something important.

But thing I observe everyday is "flattness".

What will be the Earth as observed by a farmer or a footballplayer, will it be round or will it be flat ? (The Earth.)

What if you go down to the level of athoms for observing the Earth ? - It will be a sky of "emptiness".

So ther should be at least tree way to see the earth, "roundness", "flatness" and "emptiness".

Why do I have to chose "roundness" as the dominant or significant property of the Earth all the time, when what I actually see is "flatness".

Why do I have to think about the Earth like as observed by an astronaut and not as observed from an farmer or an footballplayer "the flat Earth variant".

So isn't then more correct to say it just like it is: "The world is flat"

Why not ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Come on, man, this isn't a philosophical question. If you want to have a real discussion about local flatness in a globally curved space, check out the cosmology forums.

But don't ask this question there! You'll get me crucified!
 
  • #3
What you're looking for is the word locally, as in, the surface of the Earth is a two-sphere, and like all manifolds, is a set made up of pieces which individually look like open subsets of [itex]\bb{R}^N[/itex] such that these pieces can be sewn together smoothly.

In other words, the Earth is a two-sphere, but it looks locally flat. We don't need any philosophical discussion on the topic; you simply need an education.

- Warren
 

FAQ: Why isn't the world flat ? (Are you sure )

Why do some people believe that the world is flat?

Some people may believe that the world is flat due to misinformation, conspiracy theories, or a lack of understanding about scientific concepts.

What evidence do we have that proves the world is round?

There is overwhelming evidence that the world is round, including photographs from space, the fact that ships disappear over the horizon due to the curvature of the Earth, and the observation of different constellations in different locations on Earth.

How did ancient civilizations view the shape of the Earth?

Many ancient civilizations, such as the Greeks and Egyptians, believed in a round Earth based on observations of the stars and shadows, as well as mathematical calculations.

Can we trust modern technology and scientific research about the shape of the Earth?

Yes, modern technology and scientific research have consistently confirmed that the Earth is round. Advances in technology, such as satellites and GPS, have provided even more evidence for a round Earth.

Is there any benefit to understanding that the world is round?

Understanding that the world is round allows us to accurately navigate and map the Earth, predict and understand weather patterns, and travel around the world more efficiently. It also helps us to gain a better understanding of our place in the universe.

Back
Top