Why on earth have you locked my discussion about free will?

  • Thread starter NewToThis
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation revolved around the restrictions on discussing certain topics in the General Discussion section of a forum, and the frustration of not being able to discuss important issues. The thread was locked due to the forum's rules against philosophical discussions. The person was advised to read the rules before posting in the future.
  • #1
NewToThis
29
3
I posted it in the General Discussion section, where you have threads about the Rio Olympics and "Lame Jokes", but we can't discuss free will, even though scientist like LIbet worked on it.

Why have a General Discussion section if you won't allow general discussion, unless its about jokes and the Olympics?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
NewToThis said:
unless its about jokes and the Olympics?

That's exactly what general discussion is for.
 
  • #3
micromass said:
That's exactly what general discussion is for.

Yes, at least we can discuss the important stuff, not small issues like like a system that imprisons people to life or sentences them to the electric chair.
 
  • #4
NewToThis said:
Yes, at least we can discuss the important stuff, not small issues like like a system that imprisons people to life or sentences them to the electric chair.

Sure, let's go by your proposal and release all dangerous criminals. I don't see what needs to be discussed, it's just a stupid idea.
 
  • #5
Thread locked for moderation.
 
  • #6
NewToThis said:
I posted it in the General Discussion section, where you have threads about the Rio Olympics and "Lame Jokes", but we can't discuss free will, even though scientist like LIbet worked on it.

Why have a General Discussion section if you won't allow general discussion, unless its about jokes and the Olympics?
It was locked because we do not allow philosophical discussions and that was explained to you by the mentor that closed your thread. You should try reading the rules before you post so that you know what is allowed and aren't surprised. The rules are there for your benefit.
 

FAQ: Why on earth have you locked my discussion about free will?

Why did you lock my discussion about free will?

As a scientist, I am committed to promoting evidence-based discussions and debates. If a discussion becomes unproductive or deviates from the topic at hand, it may be necessary to lock it to maintain the integrity of the conversation.

Is this a violation of my free speech?

No, locking a discussion does not restrict anyone's right to free speech. It simply ensures that the discussion remains focused and productive for all participants.

Who gave you the authority to lock discussions?

I have been designated as a moderator for this discussion and have the responsibility to maintain a respectful and productive environment for all participants. This includes locking discussions if necessary.

Can I appeal the decision to lock the discussion?

Yes, if you feel that the discussion was unjustly locked, you can reach out to the moderator team and provide your reasoning for why the discussion should be reopened. The decision to lock or unlock a discussion ultimately lies with the moderators.

How can we continue the discussion about free will if it is locked?

While the specific discussion may be locked, you are still free to start a new discussion or find other ongoing discussions about the topic. This allows for a fresh start and a chance for the discussion to be conducted in a more productive manner.

Similar threads

Back
Top