Why smaller particles come together

  • Thread starter A Dhingra
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Particles
In summary, the question is why protons and neutrons came together first after the big bang instead of electrons. This is due to the strong nuclear force being stronger than electromagnetism, which is what attracts electrons to protons. The reasons for these forces are not fully understood, but can be observed through experiments. At much higher temperatures, understanding the reasons for these forces becomes important. Additionally, the smallest point of charge and the forces that hold it together are currently unknown as they lie at energy levels that are not yet experimentally accessible.
  • #1
A Dhingra
211
1
--- >> a question…… it is said that a few seconds after the big bang , the subatomic particles gradually lost energy and came together…….then why the protons and neutrons came together first and not the electrons ?……….. i thought ,this is possibly due to their greater mass….. but further dividing them , they are also made up of smaller units…… why these smaller units came came together…….. the main question is why the smallest particles came together and turned to the form they are in now…… obviously at very very high energy of that time they could exist individually………then what were the forces that caused them to come together……. ?

……………….. as far as the forces on small particles are concerned they are short range and with enough energy in them why would they settle... and if those forces came to bind them .. then where such forces arose from..
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
Read Steven Weinberg's "The First Three Minutes".
 
  • #3
A Dhingra said:
then why the protons and neutrons came together first and not the electrons ?

Protons and neutrons attract each other with the strong nuclear force, whereas electrons only attract to protons with electromagnetism. The strong nuclear force is stronger than EM, so the temperature you need to cause nuclei to fall apart is much higher. To heat things enough so that nuclei fall apart, you need tens of millions of degrees, whereas atoms will fall part with a few thousand.

……………….. as far as the forces on small particles are concerned they are short range and with enough energy in them why would they settle... and if those forces came to bind them .. then where such forces arose from..

Why the forces are what they are is a much more difficult question, and it's something that isn't fully understood. For things like nuclear fusion, you really don't need to understand why to see what happens since you can just heat up a reactor and see what happens.

For much, much hotter temperatures beyond current experiments, you need to start understand the reasons why things are what they are, and at that point you hit the limits of our current knowledge.
 
  • #4
Binding energies. We have experimental evidence that tells us how much energy it takes to tear neutrons, etal, apart. We infer from this particles are unstable at these energy levels. We extrapolate backwards to the point in time conditions [temperature] were sufficient to preclude them from forming and remaining stable.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
if i combine the property of possession of charge with the size of the mass...
is there any regular patter between them...

and what is charge actually and where does it come from...
as far as i have studied in my books , charges can be separated by polarization ... so what should be the smallest point of charge ... and what kind of mass it should posses...

here wat should be the force that holds the charge together...
 
  • #6
anyone...
 
  • #7
The physics necessary to answer your question are unknown. It lays at energy levels that are not yet experimentally accesible.
 
Last edited:

FAQ: Why smaller particles come together

What is the definition of "smaller particles" in this context?

In this context, smaller particles refer to microscopic particles such as atoms, molecules, or subatomic particles.

Why do smaller particles come together?

Smaller particles come together due to intermolecular forces, such as van der Waals forces or hydrogen bonding. These forces attract particles to each other and cause them to stick together.

What factors affect the coming together of smaller particles?

The strength of intermolecular forces, temperature, pressure, and the chemical properties of the particles all affect the coming together of smaller particles. For example, particles with stronger intermolecular forces will come together more easily than those with weaker forces.

What are some examples of smaller particles coming together?

Some examples of smaller particles coming together include the formation of water molecules from hydrogen and oxygen atoms, the bonding of carbon atoms to form molecules such as methane, and the aggregation of proteins to form larger structures in the body.

What are the practical applications of understanding why smaller particles come together?

Understanding why smaller particles come together is crucial in various fields, including chemistry, biology, and material science. It helps scientists design and develop new materials and medicines, understand the properties of different substances, and explain natural phenomena such as phase changes and chemical reactions.

Back
Top