Why the temperature of a car does not increase with velocity?

In summary, temperature is a measure of the rate of change of entropy with respect to energy. This means that the temperature of a system is not affected by the state of motion of the system, as long as the movement is disordered. This applies to all forms of energy, including kinetic energy, thermal energy, and internal energy. However, the movement of the molecules does play a role in the transfer of energy, as collisions and interactions increase with higher rates of movement. The concept of temperature is based on the entropy of a system, which is a relative measure and not affected by the motion of the system.
  • #1
Mohammad Sakib
4
0
We know temperature is a measure of average kinetic energy of molecules/particles of a system. Now if a car starts to move, its velocity increases so does its kinetic energy. Therefore all the molecules are gaining velocity too. Shouldn't this increase the temperatre as average kinetic energy of molecules seems to be increasing?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
Mohammad Sakib said:
We know temperature is a measure of average kinetic energy of molecules/particles of a system.

Not at all. Where did you get that?
 
  • #3
I have noticed this in some forums. Many of them also told that they are proportional
Vanadium 50 said:
Not at all. Where did you get that?
 
  • #4
Even if it were true (it is a little true for gases), it matters that the motion of the gas molecules is random vs the car's motion being in one direction.
 
  • #5
It would be a great help if anyone of you could explain me why in cases where average kinetic energy of particles is related to temperature needs to be relative to the centre of mass of a body? I know that on the basis of reference frame temperature of a body would differ a lot. But a body might have a very high velocity with respect to something actually static, however with respect to centre of mass the particles won't seem to move that fast. Why doesn't this factor affect temperatre?
 
  • #6
Mohammad Sakib said:
We know temperature is a measure of average kinetic energy of molecules/particles of a system.
This is an unfortunately common misunderstanding. Temperature (actually 1/T) is the rate of change of entropy with respect to a change in energy. At low temperature a small increase in energy gives a large increase in entropy, and vice versa at high temperature. Energy is involved, but it is about the relationship between energy and entropy.

Now, for an ideal monoatomic gas it is true that the average KE is directly proportional to the temperature. That is a specific feature of ideal monoatomic gasses, not a general rule. It doesn’t hold for many real gasses at high temperatures or pressures, and it really doesn’t hold for solids at all. It is very unfortunate that a specific rule for ideal gasses has been so over generalized that people think it applies where it doesn’t.

Mohammad Sakib said:
Summary:: Why does temperature of a car does not depend on its state of motion?

Now if a car starts to move, its velocity increases so does its kinetic energy. Therefore all the molecules are gaining velocity too. Shouldn't this increase the temperatre as average kinetic energy of molecules seems to be increasing?
The rate of change of entropy with respect to energy has not decreased, so the temperature has not increased.

Mohammad Sakib said:
But a body might have a very high velocity with respect to something actually static, however with respect to centre of mass the particles won't seem to move that fast. Why doesn't this factor affect temperatre?
Because it doesn’t affect the rate of change of entropy with respect to energy.
 
  • Like
Likes Mohammad Sakib
  • #7
Mohammad Sakib said:
It would be a great help if anyone of you could explain me why in cases where average kinetic energy of particles is related to temperature needs to be relative to the centre of mass of a body?
Imagine you put your hand up against something hot. The atoms and molecules of your hand and the object are now touching, but the hot object's atoms and molecules are moving much more vigorously than your hand's. This difference causes energy to be transferred from the hot object to your hand through all of the collisions and various interactions taking place.

The key here is that the movement of the atoms and molecules is disordered. If the movement was ordered, well, you've simply accelerated the object as a whole and instead of transferring heat, it slams into your hand at some velocity.
 
  • Like
Likes atyy and russ_watters
  • #8
Think of a bottle of gas. The bottle moves at high speed. The molecules in the bottle don't collide with each other or collide with the bottle walls any faster.

Besides, relative to the other bottles in the box, it's not moving at all. Remember, all motion is relative.

But heat the gas inside the bottle and both kinds of collisions happen more often.
 
  • #9
So basically kinetic energy, thermal energy,internal energy all these are relative but entropy isn't relative and temperature is defined based on this entropy. Isn't it?
 
  • #10
Drakkith said:
Imagine you put your hand up against something hot. The atoms and molecules of your hand and the object are now touching, but the hot object's atoms and molecules are moving much more vigorously than your hand's. This difference causes energy to be transferred from the hot object to your hand through all of the collisions and various interactions taking place.

The key here is that the movement of the atoms and molecules is disordered. If the movement was ordered, well, you've simply accelerated the object as a whole and instead of transferring heat, it slams into your hand at some velocity.
I'm not a fan of that last bit, because if you slam a car into something it will dissipate a lot of that energy as heat. IMO it is better to simply point out that if you are a passenger in the car the kinetic energy with respect to you is zero, so ordered kinetic energy can't be related to temperature because it is frame dependent (even for situations where kinetic energy works for describing temperature).
 
  • #11
Mohammad Sakib said:
So basically kinetic energy, thermal energy,internal energy all these are relative but entropy isn't relative and temperature is defined based on this entropy. Isn't it?
Speaking of Galilean relativity rather than special relativity then of those only kinetic energy is relative. All the others are not.
 
  • Like
Likes Mohammad Sakib

FAQ: Why the temperature of a car does not increase with velocity?

1. Why doesn't the temperature of a car increase with velocity?

The temperature of a car does not increase with velocity because the engine is the main source of heat in a car. As the car moves, the engine works harder and produces more heat, but the cooling system is designed to dissipate this heat and maintain a constant temperature. Additionally, the air flow around the car helps to dissipate heat, preventing a significant increase in temperature.

2. How does the cooling system in a car work to maintain temperature?

The cooling system in a car consists of a radiator, a water pump, a thermostat, and a series of hoses and pipes. As the engine produces heat, the coolant (a mixture of water and antifreeze) flows through the engine and absorbs the heat. The heated coolant then flows to the radiator, where it is cooled by air passing through the radiator fins. The cooled coolant is then circulated back to the engine, maintaining a constant temperature.

3. Can the temperature of a car increase with velocity in extreme conditions?

In extreme conditions, such as driving at high speeds on a hot day, the temperature of a car may increase slightly. This is due to the increased workload on the engine and the reduced effectiveness of the cooling system in dissipating heat. However, modern cars are designed to withstand these conditions and have systems in place to prevent overheating.

4. Is the temperature of a car affected by factors other than velocity?

Yes, the temperature of a car can be affected by other factors such as the outside temperature, the load being carried by the car, and the condition of the engine and cooling system. These factors can all impact the workload on the engine and the effectiveness of the cooling system, potentially leading to an increase in temperature.

5. What can happen if the temperature of a car does increase with velocity?

If the temperature of a car were to increase significantly with velocity, it could indicate a problem with the cooling system or engine. This could lead to overheating, which can cause damage to the engine and other components of the car. It is important to regularly maintain and monitor the cooling system to prevent any potential issues.

Back
Top