Would anyone mind checking my work? - Calc 2

In summary, the conversation discusses a student's work in Calculus 2 and their use of Maple 10 to check their results. They also mention an error in their work and discuss the level of detail they write in for their assignments. There is also a discussion about the emphasis on mathematical writing in undergraduate mathematics programs. One student shares their experience in a physics program, while another mentions their experience as a math major and the importance of writing proofs.
  • #1
opticaltempest
135
0
The images below are scanned images of work for one of my assigned problems in Calculus 2. Right now I am only concerned with integrating in order to find a position function (ignoring the constant of integration for time being).

How does it look? I am checking my work with Maple 10. I do not get the same results when I evaluate Maple's resulting function and my function at the given values for the constants. I can't find my error(s) :( Anyone care to look?

Page 1 -
http://img108.imageshack.us/img108/8109/page010dy.jpg"

Page 2 -
http://img119.imageshack.us/img119/9177/page028zi.jpg"

Page 3 -
http://img129.imageshack.us/img129/2531/page035tl.jpg"

Page 4 -
http://img129.imageshack.us/img129/456/page046xs.jpg"

Thanks
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
There is an error in the last line of the last page (page 4).
You multiplied the contents of the square brackets by -u.
But you forget to change the sign of all of the terms within the square brackets!
 
  • #3
Just out of curiosity, do you always write your work out in that much detail or was that for our benefit? I think my hand would fall off if I wrote every problem I did like that.
 
  • #4
I don't write out all of my homework in this detail. This is a more complicated problem assigned by my instructor that we turn in for a grade. Sometimes it helps out with partial credit if I make some mistakes early in the problem.

I'm anal about my organization. It can be frustrating when I take mathematics tests. I hate having to works problems in a hurry. It causes me to scribble bits and pieces of a problem all over the paper.

I wish mathematics courses, specifically calculus, would put some emphasis on mathematical writing.

When is formal mathematical writing taught in an undergraduate mathematics program?
 
  • #5
I think it would vary from place to place.

As a physics major I was expected to do some writing in my Linear Algebra and Differential Equations classes. Both of those classes had long-term final projects for which I had to write a paper and do a presentation in front of the class, those were both in my Sophomore year. In my Junior year we had long term written assignments in my Classical Mechanics class, this was a requirement by the department since they found that many Physics seniors were having a very hard time doing the kind of writing which is necessary for articles or grant applications. In my senior year (this year, next quarter) I will be expected to write and present a research piece on a subject of my choice, there's an entire 4 unit upper division writing class devoted to this.

Edit: As a Math major I would expect that you'd be doing a lot more writing, I imagine that the upper division math classes largely consist of proofs which you will be expected to write out in some detail.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
dicerandom said:
Edit: As a Math major I would expect that you'd be doing a lot more writing, I imagine that the upper division math classes largely consist of proofs which you will be expected to write out in some detail.

Yes, very much the case for me as a math major. Real analysis especially so, under grad was tough with the proofs needing to be detailed and rigorous [Rudin], but the grad version was brutal :cry: ! Necessary and sufficient conditions for some obscure theorem to hold it seems that all problems are proofs or disproofs by counter-example.
 

FAQ: Would anyone mind checking my work? - Calc 2

1. What is Calc 2?

Calc 2, short for Calculus 2, is a college-level math course that builds upon the foundations of Calculus 1. It covers topics such as techniques of integration, Taylor series, sequences, and series.

2. Why do people ask others to check their work in Calc 2?

As Calc 2 is a challenging course, students may ask others to check their work to ensure that they have solved problems correctly. This can also help them identify any mistakes or areas for improvement.

3. Is it okay to ask someone to check my work in Calc 2?

Yes, it is okay to ask for someone to check your work in Calc 2. However, it is important to note that they should only check and provide feedback, not solve the problems for you.

4. Who can I ask to check my work in Calc 2?

You can ask your classmates, professor, or a tutor to check your work in Calc 2. It is also helpful to join a study group where you can collaborate and get feedback from peers.

5. How do I know if my work in Calc 2 is correct?

One way to check if your work in Calc 2 is correct is by comparing it to the solutions provided by your professor or textbook. You can also ask someone to check your work or use online resources such as Wolfram Alpha to verify your answers.

Similar threads

Back
Top