Consciousness, at its simplest, is sentience or awareness of internal and external existence. Despite millennia of analyses, definitions, explanations and debates by philosophers and scientists, consciousness remains puzzling and controversial, being "at once the most familiar and most mysterious aspect of our lives". Perhaps the only widely agreed notion about the topic is the intuition that it exists. Opinions differ about what exactly needs to be studied and explained as consciousness. Sometimes, it is synonymous with the mind, and at other times, an aspect of it. In the past, it was one's "inner life", the world of introspection, of private thought, imagination and volition. Today, it often includes some kind of experience, cognition, feeling or perception. It may be awareness, awareness of awareness, or self-awareness. There might be different levels or orders of consciousness, or different kinds of consciousness, or just one kind with different features. Other questions include whether only humans are conscious, all animals, or even the whole universe. The disparate range of research, notions and speculations raises doubts about whether the right questions are being asked.Examples of the range of descriptions, definitions or explanations are: simple wakefulness, one's sense of selfhood or soul explored by "looking within"; being a metaphorical "stream" of contents, or being a mental state, mental event or mental process of the brain; having phanera or qualia and subjectivity; being the 'something that it is like' to 'have' or 'be' it; being the "inner theatre" or the executive control system of the mind.
There is soooo much misinformation out there that for the non-physicist, it is difficult to know whether to trust one source or not.
So, one thing I do not understand is, based on what I've read, how QM does or does not require consciousness. It seems a debate that has been going on almost...
What are your opinions on this book? I know that many physicists like to present even the experimental results of quantum mechanics in a distorted way; does this book do so?
All I am looking for is a resource where I can learn, in layman's terms for now, about quantum mechanics. I don't want to...
Sorry to post what seems to me a somewhat bizarre question, but in some of my discussions regarding the cancer/bad luck study I have been assured physicists do not believe in consciousness. I would assume this would need some nuance, but I just thought I would put it out in a gross manner first...
I've read a lot of posts talking about quantum consciousness, and it seems the general consensus is that it is crack, woo, psuedoscience etc. But then I found a news feed that pointed to this,
Travis John Adrian Craddock, Douglas Friesen, Jonathan Mane, Stuart Hameroff, and Jack A. Tuszynski...
Hello. I am a complete layman in regards to having any in depth knowledge of Physics whatsoever, I am interested on research into the areas of consciousness and I wanted to ask questions about Penrose and Hameroff's Orchestrated Objective Reduction Theory that claims that Consciousness derives...
So this is pretty recent but it seems they found that consciousness is somehow linked to QM at least in how the brain works.I hope this doesent mean that thoughts/consciousness have an effect on reality.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1571064513001619
I'd like to ask a question to the members of the Quantum Physics board.
Reading several articles regarding Quantum Suicide, Copenhagen Interpretation, Paradox, Multiverse theory and Biocentrism has made me wonder..
1) Is it possible for us to be conscious in two different "Parallel...
I have the be careful because I don't want this topic to be about philosophy. I want to know what science thinks about consciousness. Is there a global agreement on what it might be? A physical thing like a gene or is it linked in with dna?
There must be some kind of scientific view on what...
Any consciousness based approach to QM will be dismissed as woo in the main forum.
However it's admitted that (with refernece to the double slit experiment):
"To be clear, the rule for interference in these cases: if it is possible, in principle, to know which slit the particle goes...
"Mysticism in Quantum Mechanics": the forgotten controversy by Juan Miguel Marin, Harvard, Eur. J. Phys. 30 (2009) 807 - 822. How's that Mr. Mentor? Or are you going to censor this post also? Small-minded world physicists, like the 'flatlander-earth-centric' astronomers of old better take...
Is there a discussion on this board of the possibility that consciousness is the missing link in a true unified field theory? Or is this considered heresy, not mainstream, a homework question, too out of the box or just a confounding question as everyone with an open mind here knows that it's...
How is it possible a patient looses consciousness and at the same time remain alive?
in anesthesia, coma or unconsciousness due to injury/accident.
Because I believe it is the consciousness that give life to a living being. Isn't it become an inert body without consciousness.
Or in...
Its a tough question to ask and I am looking for a scientific answer.
How can we talk in our mind? I mean when we think about something it feels as if we are talking in our head. They are multiple arguments going on in our head and you can listen to it. What is it?
This question arose when...
The individual's perception of time has been studied for decades with theories such as the strength model and the inference model by William Friedman. Along with many psychological tests, many neuroscientists have observed the beginnings of an internal clock that exists in humans (which can be...
I'm sure many of you have heard of the ship of Theseus. If not,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus
"The ship wherein Theseus and the youth of Athens returned [from Crete] had thirty oars, and was preserved by the Athenians down even to the time of Demetrius Phalereus, for they took...
[I'm using the word "consciousness" to basically mean "capability to have an experience".]
Assume there was a machine that could instantly destroy and/or create a perfect replication of you. It does both of these functions and incinerates you, making a perfect copy of you 10 feet away.
Most...
First off, apologies. I'm not as advanced as most on this forum and hope that my (less than ideal) pairing of physics with science-fiction will not sound completely stupid.
Nevertheless, I came here to find a community who actually knows about the physical sciences so I can correct any...
new article (note, the above quote is from the news article, so subject to journalist interpretations):
http://neurosciencenews.com/conscious-perception-global-neural-networks-prefrontal-cortex/
peer reviewed article:
http://www.cell.com/neuron/abstract/S0896-6273(12)00380-7
Consciousness is still a big mystery, and I've always wondered what causes it. I've decided that it is most likely one of two possibilities: that consciousness is "simple," or "complex."
1) If consciousness is simple, then that means that it is simply an inherent property of the universe...
I'm wondering whether physicists in the 1930's ever had experimental reason to interpret, for example, Schrödinger's cat, as a true paradox (because of the role of a human observer). Why didn't they default to Bohr's interpretation, that an interaction with a geiger-counter, or any classically...
Hi,
After some (limited) reading I've written an article on the captioned subject :
http://3fathom.dyndns.org/QM-Consciousness.htm
I post it here for feedback. Intellectual stimulation, please!
Thanks,
Stewart
Recently I've watched some riveting vids where conciousness is explored from a scientific perspective. Please have a look and comment. The Penrose video is long, but amazingly planned and executed, regardless of the guys disposistion...
Stuart Hameroff: Link removed (solid in scientific...
Hi, fellow curious minds,
I believe that human neuro structures are microscopic and thus within the realm of QM.From my basic physics knowledge, it seems to me that QM's probability interpretation of micro-phenomena is related to human volition. Every moment our consciousness are choosing...
I've been following the work of Professor Stuart Hammeroff et al. and his group's work on microtubules as best I can, and I simply wish to know: are there any experimental tests currently going on either on Earth or in Space that may potentially affect the quantum coherence of human (or other)...
So, as the title says, I'm curious to know what (theoretically) happens to human consciousness after we pass away. Obviously no one knows for sure, I'm just curious to learn more about this particular topic, from a scientific perspective. I'll admit, I'm curious about this because in July of...
Alot of people are trying to prove its real. I am a noob at quantum physics but I've been reading up a lot about it.I took physics in high school and did really well but this quantum consciousness idea is driving me crazy.
Can someone tell me exactly why quantum consciousness isn't true...
I know dumb question but If you observe with your eyes using a laser pen and two microscope slits does the wave collapse as opposed to closing your eyes while the light passes through the slits and then observing the defraction pattern on the wall?
Also is it the measuring device that causes the...
A very intriguing TED talk discusses the similarities between consciousness arising in the brain (via Dan Dennett)and search algorithms. Would LOVE to get some more detailed insight into this from the community here.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RGF9NbPFfRo"
This concerns the the use of QM to explain consciousness. I'm looking for any weaknesses in this paper.
With an interest in physics, but being a lay person I understand little of the more complex ideas. Therefore, I'm somewhat at a loss to notice incorrect usage of such ideas most of the time...
In Daniel Dennett's Consciousness Explained, he described and explained how subjective experience or qualia or consciousness in general is just a result of biology and nothing more. The word "Consciousness" is very broad and can become vague so let's just focus on qualia or internal subjective...
Hello:
I know it's a rather subjective title. But I am no expert in the subject and I've read a lot of information in the Internet that is contradictory.
I have read that the collapse of the wave function requires interaction with an observer. But is that collapse in any way related to the...
OK, what is the difference between the experiences of
1. A person in a dreamless sleep.
2. An organism without a brain, ie plant or bacteria
3. A dead person or a rock.
I asked this on another forum, they told me sleeping people feel everything but don't think about it/remember it, plants...
OK, if you=consciousness and consciousness=awareness does it mean you die when you sleep since you're not aware? And when you wake up it isn't you because it's a new awareness?
Also since there are tiny temporal gaps between when you receive brain waves does it mean that you die many times in...
Hey guys! Go easy on me. I'm here to learn.
This is a fascinating subject to me. I'm not trying to recreate a topic. I actually googled this topic and found this site, but the thread was locked. If I missed another similar thread feel free to redirect me.
Opening the brutal topic of...
Time and relationships (or, "consciousness" per Martin Heidegger)
In this forum we focus again and again on questions about “consciousness” – and I think there’s a deep reason why the meaning of this term tends to remain so unclear. Basically what we’re trying to understand is how our...
Does the brain create consciousness (C)? Does C originate in brains? Is C limited to brains?
Many people think they already know the answer to these questions. They might have a religious conviction about souls and believe the answer is "no". Or they might have a misunderstanding of...
I couldn't determine exactly what section this should fit into, considering that it does cover philosophy and most likely violate the QM section I figured it's best here. If the Mods feel otherwise please let me know.
I realize putting this thought to paper is like pinning a cloud to the...
Is the field of "Consciousness Studies" legitimate? Or is this a fraud?
Hi everyone!
First of all, I wasn't entirely sure whether this should be posted here or in General Discussion. If this is the wrong forum,please accept my apologies.
Now to topic: Recently, in our college's science...
I'm a physics student and I graduate in a few months. I have been looking for PhD's because I want to carry on learning physics but have so far struggled to find a PhD subject that really caught my eye.
I do, however, have an interest in the brain, the mind and consciousness (although I have no...
Taken from an entirely empirical standpoint, the true nature of Consciousness should be the Chinese room argument, that it is nothing but an illusion created by the interactions of billions of neurons, electrical and chemical signals. Supposedly this would disprove "The Human Soul" and...
In the market one can find a lot of Phi related numbers in time and price. But also many cubic.
http://img836.imageshack.us/img836/2079/image1czh.jpg
This is the stock Google. Why would you say this occur? It´s in calendar days. +- 2-3 days.
0,382 and 0,786 - I guess you know the relation...
Does consciousness cause thoughts?
This question is central to the debate concerning free will.
1. Effect ( by definition) cannot precede cause.
2. It is impossible to be conscious of a thought before you think it.
3. Therefore, it is impossible for consciousness to cause thoughts.
Hello I am new to this forum and was not sure where to post some thoughts I have. First of all let me compose why I even care to consider the question of consciousness. I want to first stress I do not have an education in Mathematics or physics. Also am not a good typer. Thank you ahead time for...
Hello everyone, I just decided to register here after stumbling upon this place a few days ago. After lurking for some considerable amount of time reading all sorts of intellectually and philosophically stimulating topics, I figured I should join because this is just the sort of message board I...
This might sound stupid but, does consciousness = reality? I don't know if that makes sense or not, but I guess what I'm trying to ask is, actually, I don't really know what I'm trying to ask... these type of thoughts are all new to me
So to start things off, here are a couple of questions.
So how much of consciousness do you think has been explained?
I think that we know a fair amount about consciousness (thanks to neuroscience) but the question still stands, how subjective experience arise from the physical processes that...