At a disadvantage for hiring with BA math, MS Mech. Eng?

In summary, the discussion highlights concerns regarding the competitiveness of candidates with a Bachelor's degree in Mathematics and a Master's in Mechanical Engineering in the job market. It suggests that while technical skills are valuable, employers may prefer candidates with more directly relevant experience or specialized education in mechanical engineering. The dialogue emphasizes the importance of showcasing applicable skills and experiences to overcome potential hiring disadvantages.
  • #1
insupliquitous
7
1
I have a math BA and have been teaching HS for the past few years.
Thinking of going back for my MS in MechE with the goal of becoming an engineer. There is a program which will allow me to take around 6-7 undergrad MechE classes (physics 1, CAD, statics, fluid dynamics, thermodynamics, mechanics of materials, etc) and then will allow me to move onto a MechE masters. My BA in math counts for 5 math engineering core courses I also would have had to take.

I am curious whether I would be at a disadvantage for hiring if I did this. Would someone with a BS in MechE and no MS be favored over a BA math, MS MechE?

The other option would be to get a second bachelor's, but I have heard that since I have a math degree already, I might as well go on to the masters.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
insupliquitous said:
There is a program which will allow me to take around 6-7 undergrad MechE classes (physics 1, CAD, statics, fluid dynamics, thermodynamics, mechanics of materials, etc) and then will allow me to move onto a MechE masters. My BA in math counts for 5 math engineering core courses I also would have had to take.
How do [courses you took for BA Math + remedial undergrad courses you plan to take as part of your MS ME program] compare to courses taken for BS ME at the school you are considering for your MS ME? That would be a good place to start. Courses would include labs and projects and undergrad thesis (if applicable).
 
  • #3
CrysPhys said:
How do [courses you took for BA Math + remedial undergrad courses you plan to take as part of your MS ME program] compare to courses taken for BS ME at the school you are considering for your MS ME? That would be a good place to start. Courses would include labs and projects and undergrad thesis (if applicable).
From the BS ME at the same school, I would be missing:
- Intro to engineering/design
- Materials science
- Instrumentation
- Heat transfer
- Senior lab 2 semesters
- Four electives

Seems pretty significant. But apparently not strictly necessary?
I think if I went for the second bachelor's it could take 3 years.
 
  • #4
insupliquitous said:
From the BS ME at the same school, I would be missing:
- Intro to engineering/design
- Materials science
- Instrumentation
- Heat transfer
- Senior lab 2 semesters
- Four electives

Seems pretty significant. But apparently not strictly necessary?
I think if I went for the second bachelor's it could take 3 years.
* Are the four electives specifically ME courses?

* Do you know what field you plan to work in after you complete your MS ME? E.g., I know one guy who went to work for an auto manufacturer; another who does HVAC design for large commercial buildings.

* Does the school have listings of alumni who completed the specific MS ME program (non-ME bachelor's)? If so, where did they find jobs afterwards?
 
  • #5
CrysPhys said:
Does the school have listings of alumni who completed the specific MS ME program (non-ME bachelor's)? If so, where did they find jobs afterwards?
This.

In the abstract, this is going to be a tough one to answer. What will an unknown hiring manager at an unknown company looking for someone for an unknown job think of this application in the context of other, unknown applicants,. Your background may bring you towards the top, or towards the bottom.

That said, I think the biggest issue is that while your competition was spending years doing engineering, you weren't. And there's really not much that can be done about that.
 

FAQ: At a disadvantage for hiring with BA math, MS Mech. Eng?

Will my BA in Math be seen as a disadvantage when applying for mechanical engineering positions?

Not necessarily. While a BA in Math is not directly related to Mechanical Engineering, it demonstrates strong analytical and problem-solving skills. Employers often value these skills, and your MS in Mechanical Engineering will show that you have the necessary technical knowledge for the role.

How can I leverage my BA in Math to my advantage when applying for engineering jobs?

You can highlight the quantitative and analytical skills you developed during your BA in Math. Emphasize how these skills complement your engineering knowledge and can be applied to solving complex engineering problems. Additionally, you can mention any relevant projects or coursework that involved mathematical modeling or simulations.

Should I expect a lower starting salary because of my non-traditional educational background?

Salary offers are typically based on a combination of your educational background, relevant experience, and the specific demands of the job. While some employers might offer a lower starting salary initially, your MS in Mechanical Engineering is a strong credential that should help you negotiate a competitive salary. Demonstrating your skills and value during the interview process can also positively influence salary offers.

Will I face challenges in job interviews due to my BA in Math?

Potentially, but you can mitigate this by preparing to explain how your BA in Math complements your engineering skills. Be ready to discuss specific examples where your mathematical background has benefited your engineering work. This will help interviewers see the unique value you bring to the table.

Are there specific industries or roles where my combined background in Math and Mechanical Engineering would be particularly beneficial?

Yes, industries such as aerospace, automotive, robotics, and data-driven engineering fields highly value strong analytical skills combined with engineering expertise. Roles that involve computational modeling, simulations, or optimization problems are particularly well-suited for someone with your background.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
22
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
3K
Replies
21
Views
712
Back
Top