Programs At a disadvantage for hiring with BA math, MS Mech. Eng?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the transition from a BA in Mathematics and high school teaching to pursuing a Master's in Mechanical Engineering (MechE). The individual is evaluating whether to take several undergraduate MechE courses before entering the master's program or to pursue a second bachelor's degree in MechE. Concerns are raised about potential hiring disadvantages compared to candidates with a BS in MechE, particularly regarding the lack of hands-on experience and specific coursework like materials science and heat transfer. The importance of comparing the coursework from the BA and planned MechE classes to the BS MechE curriculum is emphasized, as well as the relevance of alumni job placements from the master's program. Ultimately, the discussion highlights the uncertainty of how hiring managers will perceive the applicant's unique educational background compared to traditional candidates, noting that the lack of engineering experience could be a significant factor in hiring decisions.
insupliquitous
Messages
7
Reaction score
1
I have a math BA and have been teaching HS for the past few years.
Thinking of going back for my MS in MechE with the goal of becoming an engineer. There is a program which will allow me to take around 6-7 undergrad MechE classes (physics 1, CAD, statics, fluid dynamics, thermodynamics, mechanics of materials, etc) and then will allow me to move onto a MechE masters. My BA in math counts for 5 math engineering core courses I also would have had to take.

I am curious whether I would be at a disadvantage for hiring if I did this. Would someone with a BS in MechE and no MS be favored over a BA math, MS MechE?

The other option would be to get a second bachelor's, but I have heard that since I have a math degree already, I might as well go on to the masters.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
insupliquitous said:
There is a program which will allow me to take around 6-7 undergrad MechE classes (physics 1, CAD, statics, fluid dynamics, thermodynamics, mechanics of materials, etc) and then will allow me to move onto a MechE masters. My BA in math counts for 5 math engineering core courses I also would have had to take.
How do [courses you took for BA Math + remedial undergrad courses you plan to take as part of your MS ME program] compare to courses taken for BS ME at the school you are considering for your MS ME? That would be a good place to start. Courses would include labs and projects and undergrad thesis (if applicable).
 
CrysPhys said:
How do [courses you took for BA Math + remedial undergrad courses you plan to take as part of your MS ME program] compare to courses taken for BS ME at the school you are considering for your MS ME? That would be a good place to start. Courses would include labs and projects and undergrad thesis (if applicable).
From the BS ME at the same school, I would be missing:
- Intro to engineering/design
- Materials science
- Instrumentation
- Heat transfer
- Senior lab 2 semesters
- Four electives

Seems pretty significant. But apparently not strictly necessary?
I think if I went for the second bachelor's it could take 3 years.
 
insupliquitous said:
From the BS ME at the same school, I would be missing:
- Intro to engineering/design
- Materials science
- Instrumentation
- Heat transfer
- Senior lab 2 semesters
- Four electives

Seems pretty significant. But apparently not strictly necessary?
I think if I went for the second bachelor's it could take 3 years.
* Are the four electives specifically ME courses?

* Do you know what field you plan to work in after you complete your MS ME? E.g., I know one guy who went to work for an auto manufacturer; another who does HVAC design for large commercial buildings.

* Does the school have listings of alumni who completed the specific MS ME program (non-ME bachelor's)? If so, where did they find jobs afterwards?
 
CrysPhys said:
Does the school have listings of alumni who completed the specific MS ME program (non-ME bachelor's)? If so, where did they find jobs afterwards?
This.

In the abstract, this is going to be a tough one to answer. What will an unknown hiring manager at an unknown company looking for someone for an unknown job think of this application in the context of other, unknown applicants,. Your background may bring you towards the top, or towards the bottom.

That said, I think the biggest issue is that while your competition was spending years doing engineering, you weren't. And there's really not much that can be done about that.
 
I'm going to make this one quick since I have little time. Background: Throughout my life I have always done good in Math. I almost always received 90%+, and received easily upwards of 95% when I took normal-level HS Math courses. When I took Grade 9 "De-Streamed" Math (All students must take "De-Streamed" in Canada), I initially had 98% until I got very sick and my mark had dropped to 95%. The Physics teachers and Math teachers talked about me as if I were some sort of genius. Then, an...
Bit Britain-specific but I was wondering, what's the best path to take for A-Levels out of the following (I know Y10 seems a bit early to be thinking about A-levels, but my choice will impact what I do this year/ in y11) I (almost) definitely want to do physics at University - so keep that in mind... The subjects that I'm almost definitely going to take are Maths, Further Maths and Physics, and I'm taking a fast track programme which means that I'll be taking AS computer science at the end...
After a year of thought, I decided to adjust my ratio for applying the US/EU(+UK) schools. I mostly focused on the US schools before, but things are getting complex and I found out that Europe is also a good place to study. I found some institutes that have professors with similar interests. But gaining the information is much harder than US schools (like you have to contact professors in advance etc). For your information, I have B.S. in engineering (low GPA: 3.2/4.0) in Asia - one SCI...

Similar threads

Back
Top