Child Prodigies: Comparing Math and Physics

  • Thread starter Thread starter ode_to_joy
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights the observation that there appears to be a greater number of math prodigies compared to physics prodigies. Participants express curiosity about the long-term career success of prodigies versus non-prodigies, questioning whether prodigies achieve significantly better outcomes. Concerns are raised about the emotional and mental effects of pushing talented children, with the potential for burnout or breakdowns. The insights of mathematician Terry Tao on the experiences of child prodigies are mentioned, emphasizing the importance of understanding the balance between natural talent and external pressure. The conversation also touches on the notion that even renowned figures like Mozart, often viewed as naturally gifted, underwent training and pressure to excel.
Physics news on Phys.org
I also wonder what proportion of prodigies actually end up with significantly more successful careers than non-prodigies
 
wukunlin said:
I also wonder what proportion of prodigies actually end up with significantly more successful careers than non-prodigies

That is a good point.

When children show a lot of talent and end up being pushed, you wonder what effect that will have on them emotionally and mentally in other ways.

They might be pushed too hard and have some kind of breakdown or burnout completely.

Terry Tao has written a lot of things on the subject of child prodigies (on his experience anyway), and there are some good lessons and insight that other "up and coming" prodigies and their parents, guardians, and teachers should be aware of.
 
I don't know if the statistic include those who have been 'trained or being pushed'. But I mean those naturally born geniuses like Mozart. (Mozart was not a scientist though :))
 
ode_to_joy said:
I don't know if the statistic include those who have been 'trained or being pushed'. But I mean those naturally born geniuses like Mozart. (Mozart was not a scientist though :))
Mozart was "trained or pushed", though.
 
https://www.newsweek.com/robert-redford-dead-hollywood-live-updates-2130559 Apparently Redford was a somewhat poor student, so was headed to Europe to study art and painting, but stopped in New York and studied acting. Notable movies include Barefoot in the Park (1967 with Jane Fonda), Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969, with Paul Newma), Jeremiah Johnson, the political drama The Candidate (both 1972), The Sting (1973 with Paul Newman), the romantic dramas The Way We Were (1973), and...
Back
Top