David Morin classical mechanics Problem 2.6: Disk held up by a massless string

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving Problem 2.6 from David Morin's classical mechanics, specifically regarding the normal force acting on a disk held by a massless string. The initial calculations establish that the tension T equals 0.5 Mg. The confusion arises in the second part, where the normal force N is incorrectly defined, leading to an erroneous conclusion of Mg equaling zero. It is clarified that the normal force must be treated as a force per unit length, dependent on the length of the arc, rather than a constant value. Understanding this relationship is crucial for accurately applying the principles of mechanics to the problem.
John100861
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
(a) A disk of mass M and radius R is held up by a massless string, as
shown in Fig. 2.12. The surface of the disk is frictionless. What is
the tension in the string? What is the normal force per unit length
that the string applies to the disk?
Relevant Equations
ΣF=0
Screenshot 2020-07-05 at 4.58.03 PM.png

The first part is easy, we have 2T= Mg
T= 0.5 Mg
Now for the second part where I'm having trouble understanding Morin's solution:
I take the normal force on a small circle arc to be N, we know that the y component of the normal force must be balance with Mg for the whole disk, therefore
Ny = Nsin(θ)
dNy= Ncos(θ)dθ
Ncos(θ)dθ= Mg
And this is where I have trouble, I end up with Mg= 0 when plugging in the limits [0, π]
Morin's solution suggests that the normal force in the arc should be written as Ndθ but I don't understand why. Please point out what's wrong with my approach, and help me understand the solution, thanks.
.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
You cannot define N in that way since it depends on the length of arc. Better to consider N as a force per unit length.
Pinpointing your error is not possible until you say how you are defining theta.
If it is the angle between the dashed line and the radius to an element ##rd\theta## of arc, the normal force is ##Nrd\theta##, and its Y component is ##Nr\cos(\theta)d\theta##.
 
haruspex said:
You cannot define N in that way since it depends on the length of arc.
Hi thanks for your reply! Yes I'm defining that to be theta. Could you please elaborate on this? It's still not clear to me why I can't define N that way.
 
John100861 said:
Hi thanks for your reply! Yes I'm defining that to be theta. Could you please elaborate on this? It's still not clear to me why I can't define N that way.
The normal force on a small circle of arc will depend on the length of the arc. So you need it as (some variable) x length of arc, i.e. as a force per unit length.
 
  • Like
Likes John100861
haruspex said:
The normal force on a small circle of arc will depend on the length of the arc. So you need it as (some variable) x length of arc, i.e. as a force per unit length.
Why does it depend on the length of the arc?
 
John100861 said:
Why does it depend on the length of the arc?
The tension in the string exerts a pressure on the cylinder. Over a small (effectively almost straight) section of arc the force is the pressure times the length.
 
Thread 'Voltmeter readings for this circuit with switches'
TL;DR Summary: I would like to know the voltmeter readings on the two resistors separately in the picture in the following cases , When one of the keys is closed When both of them are opened (Knowing that the battery has negligible internal resistance) My thoughts for the first case , one of them must be 12 volt while the other is 0 The second case we'll I think both voltmeter readings should be 12 volt since they are both parallel to the battery and they involve the key within what the...
Thread 'Correct statement about a reservoir with an outlet pipe'
The answer to this question is statements (ii) and (iv) are correct. (i) This is FALSE because the speed of water in the tap is greater than speed at the water surface (ii) I don't even understand this statement. What does the "seal" part have to do with water flowing out? Won't the water still flow out through the tap until the tank is empty whether the reservoir is sealed or not? (iii) In my opinion, this statement would be correct. Increasing the gravitational potential energy of the...
Back
Top