Different way to find center of mass of Hollow hemisphere

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on finding the center of mass of a hollow hemisphere, highlighting confusion over the transition from one equation to another. The original poster struggles with the formulation of their approach, particularly regarding the y-coordinate of an infinitesimal mass element. There is a suggestion to clarify the question and improve the presentation of the equations for better understanding. The importance of clear communication in mathematical problems is emphasized, as well as the need for accurate notation. Overall, the thread underscores the challenges of solving complex physics problems and the necessity for precise explanations.
BlackUniverse
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
I want to find out center of mass of Hollow hemisphere using a vertical half ring element [Pls i know how to find it using a horizontal ring]
Relevant Equations
All eulqutions are in the pic.
Here is how I tried to solve it but I don't know how I got formula for disc.
Before this I tried to solve for half disc using a vertical element and it worked but not for this. Why?
 

Attachments

  • 17579254936335414275486953583308.webp
    17579254936335414275486953583308.webp
    56.6 KB · Views: 5
  • 17579258203435021145613103920118.webp
    17579258203435021145613103920118.webp
    60.2 KB · Views: 6
  • 17579258745996416888257079582409.webp
    17579258745996416888257079582409.webp
    88.8 KB · Views: 1
Physics news on Phys.org
You may get better/more answers if you formulate a more specific question rather than just this "check my work" format with three pages of hand written formulas with not much explanations of what they mean. Marking hand-written homework is a very tedious job.
 
  • Agree
Likes TensorCalculus, jbriggs444, kuruman and 1 other person
Half disk CM.webp
Specifically, how do you get from equation (1) to equation (2)? (see figure).

In equation (1) symbol ##y## stands for "the y-coordinate of infinitesimally small element ##dm##."

It seems that for ##dm## you are using a semi-circle of width ##dx## and radius ##x##. In equation (2) what did you use for its y-coordinate and why ?
 
If you use x as the horizontall coordinate, the width of these strips is not dx.
 
It might also be more readable if you take some time to write it all out in TeX. Guide here. :)
 
Maths and physics are hard enough without doing things the wrong way!
 
PeroK said:
Maths and physics are hard enough without doing things the wrong way!
Did you mean to say
Maths and physics are hard enough without trying to do things the harder way?
 
Back
Top