Electrophilic nature of Carbon in CO2

AI Thread Summary
The carbon in carbon dioxide (CO2) is considered electrophilic due to its oxidation state of +4, despite the molecule's symmetrical structure that results in no overall partial positive charge. The symmetry of CO2 leads to the cancellation of dipoles, which means that while the carbon does not exhibit a formal or partial positive charge, it can still act as an electrophile in organic addition reactions. The polar nature of the C=O bonds indicates the presence of partial charges at the bond level, even if they do not contribute to an overall charge on the carbon atom. This distinction clarifies how carbon can still participate in reactions as an electrophile. Understanding the interplay between oxidation state, molecular symmetry, and bond polarity is crucial in discussing the electrophilic nature of carbon in CO2.
Qube
Gold Member
Messages
461
Reaction score
1
How is the carbon in carbon dioxide electrophilic? There is no partial positive charge on the carbon in carbon dioxide because the molecule is symmetrical.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You can consider one of the pi bond in C-O bond to jump to O, thus leaving C with electron deficit, thus making it electrophile.

If you are talking about how it takes part as electrophile in various organic addition reaction, this is the way it works.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
I think I got it; the carbon in carbon dioxide is electrophilic because the oxidation state of the carbon in that molecule is +4. I think what you described is what happens when carbon acts as an electrophile; I was just looking for why and I didn't see that using formal and partial charges - formal charge analysis says the carbon is neutral; partial charge analysis says that the carbon bears no partial charge because the dipoles formed by the oxygens cancel out, but oxidation state analysis tells me that the electrons bide their time with the oxygens instead of the carbon. Thank you :).
 
Qube said:
There is no partial positive charge on the carbon in carbon dioxide because the molecule is symmetrical.

I don't understand the argument. Linear molecule O=C=O having partial positive charge on the carbon and half negative charges on oxygens is quite symmetrical.
 
Borek said:
I don't understand the argument. Linear molecule O=C=O having partial positive charge on the carbon and half negative charges on oxygens is quite symmetrical.

Oops, I can see it now. So even if the dipoles cancel out, there can be partial charges?
 
Partial charges are seen in terms of individual bond. Since C=O bond is polar, you are expected to see partial charges.
 
AGNuke said:
Partial charges are seen in terms of individual bond. Since C=O bond is polar, you are expected to see partial charges.

Ah, good distinction. Thank you :)!
 
Back
Top