Equivalence of diffeomorphism definitions

In summary, the conversation discusses the definition of diffeomorphism and its relation to smooth manifolds. The first definition from Wolfram MathWorld states that a diffeomorphism is a differentiable map with a differentiable inverse, while the Encyclopedia of Math adds that it must also be bijective. The conversation also touches on the various definitions of smoothness and how it can vary in different contexts. The main takeaway is that it is important to consider the specific definition being used in a given situation.
  • #1
Avatrin
245
6
Hi

Lets start off with the definition of diffeomorphism from Wolfram MathWorld:
A diffeomorphism is a map between manifolds which is differentiable and has a differentiable inverse.

The issue is that I am learning about smooth manifolds, and in the books I've read, the map has to be smooth and have a smooth inverse. Also, the definition above doesn't say that it has to be bijective. However, the Encyclopedia of Math does.

So, are these definitions equivalent? If not, when are they equivalent?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Avatrin said:
the definition above doesn't say that it has to be bijective. However, the Encyclopedia of Math does.
It says the map has an inverse, which means it is injective. In practice the focus will be restricted to the image of the map, so we have a bijection between the domain and the image of the map.

Smoothness is strictly stronger than differentiability. Consider two identical manifolds that are infinite cylinders. I think it should be easy to construct a bijective, differential map between the two that is not smooth. Just take a bijection on ##S^1## that is once but not twice differentiable and extend it parallel to the cylinder's axis.
 
  • #3
you should get used to the fact that most terms have many different definitions, so the point is not to ask for a definition that will always be valid in every seting, but to remember in every specific context to ask what that author's definition is. In your case e.g. even the word "smooth" has no universal definition: e.g. in Milnor's little book, Topology from the differentiable viewpoint, it means C^infinity, but in most books, e.g. Mo Hirsh's Differential Topology, it means C^1 or even less precisely, C^r with r ≥ 1.
 
  • Like
Likes Avatrin

FAQ: Equivalence of diffeomorphism definitions

What is the definition of a diffeomorphism?

A diffeomorphism is a smooth and invertible mapping between two differentiable manifolds. It preserves the smoothness and differentiability of the functions involved.

What are the two common definitions of diffeomorphism?

The two common definitions of diffeomorphism are the geometric definition and the algebraic definition. The geometric definition focuses on the smoothness and invertibility of the mapping, while the algebraic definition focuses on the differentiability of the functions involved.

Are the two definitions of diffeomorphism equivalent?

Yes, the two definitions of diffeomorphism are equivalent. This means that if a mapping satisfies one definition, it automatically satisfies the other definition as well.

How are the two definitions of diffeomorphism related?

The geometric definition of diffeomorphism is a special case of the algebraic definition. This means that if a mapping satisfies the geometric definition, it automatically satisfies the algebraic definition as well. However, the reverse is not always true.

Why are there two different definitions of diffeomorphism?

The two definitions of diffeomorphism were developed to capture different aspects of the concept. The geometric definition focuses on the geometric properties of the mapping, while the algebraic definition focuses on the analytical properties. Both definitions are important in different areas of mathematics and physics.

Back
Top