Equivalent Sums Homework: Solve (-6/π) ∑n Even Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter Calu
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Equivalent Sums
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around understanding the equivalence of two sums: (-6/π) ∑n even (cos(nx))/(n²-9) and (-6/π) ∑∞n=1 (cos(2nx))/(4n²-9). A change of variable, n = 2m, in the first sum demonstrates that it can be transformed into the second sum, confirming their equivalence. The factor of 2 in the cosine function corresponds to summing over even integers, while the factor of 4 in the denominator arises from squaring the change of variable. The participants clarify that both sums represent infinite sets, emphasizing the correct interpretation of the indices. Understanding this transformation resolves the initial confusion regarding the sums' equivalence.
Calu
Messages
73
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



I have that, for n ∈ ℕ, (-6/π) ∑n even (cos(nx))/(n2-9) is equivalent to (-6/π) ∑n=1 (cos(2nx))/(4n2-9). I don't understand how the two sums are equivalent to each other.

Homework Equations



I honestly have no idea what may be relevant, other than what is above.

The Attempt at a Solution



I'm making a guess that the factor of 2 within the cosine function in the second sum allows the sum to be the same as summing over the even natural numbers. However I'm not sure that's correct, and I'm still unsure where the factor of 4 comes from in front of the n2 in the denominator, other than it is 22.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Calu said:

Homework Statement



I have that, for n ∈ ℕ, (-6/π) ∑n even (cos(nx))/(n2-9) is equivalent to (-6/π) ∑n=1 (cos(2nx))/(4n2-9). I don't understand how the two sums are equivalent to each other.

Homework Equations



I honestly have no idea what may be relevant, other than what is above.

The Attempt at a Solution



I'm making a guess that the factor of 2 within the cosine function in the second sum allows the sum to be the same as summing over the even natural numbers. However I'm not sure that's correct, and I'm still unsure where the factor of 4 comes from in front of the n2 in the denominator, other than it is 22.

Make the change of variable ##n = 2m## in the first sum and see what you get.
 
LCKurtz said:
Make the change of variable ##n = 2m## in the first sum and see what you get.

Right I see, this would give me what I have in the second sum, obviously with m substituted for n. So can this change of variable be used as I'm summing over twice as many integers?
 
Calu said:
Right I see, this would give me what I have in the second sum, obviously with m substituted for n. So can this change of variable be used as I'm summing over twice as many integers?

All the integers is not "twice as many integers". They are both infinite sets. But you just need to note that all even integers are given by ##2m## as ##m = 1,2,3...##. The index goes through all the natural numbers but ##2m## gives all the evens.
 
LCKurtz said:
All the integers is not "twice as many integers". They are both infinite sets. But you just need to note that all even integers are given by ##2m## as ##m = 1,2,3...##. The index goes through all the natural numbers but ##2m## gives all the evens.

I see now, thanks for your help.
 
Back
Top