- #1
gravenewworld
- 1,132
- 26
Free Will?
Do humans really have free will? If god is an all knowing and all loving being than wouldn't god know before hand what decision you would make if you were presented with a "choice" ? If you don't choose what god already knows what you will choose than god is not perfect. But if you do choose what god knows what you will choose than you can't have free will. Say a person has an option of choosing between A and B, but I know that the person willl choose B before. What really is the difference then, of only offering that person option B? Are humans really just following a set path intended for them by god?
(BTW please if you respond please stick to the topic of free will, not on whether god exists or not)
Do humans really have free will? If god is an all knowing and all loving being than wouldn't god know before hand what decision you would make if you were presented with a "choice" ? If you don't choose what god already knows what you will choose than god is not perfect. But if you do choose what god knows what you will choose than you can't have free will. Say a person has an option of choosing between A and B, but I know that the person willl choose B before. What really is the difference then, of only offering that person option B? Are humans really just following a set path intended for them by god?
(BTW please if you respond please stick to the topic of free will, not on whether god exists or not)