How Can an Infinite Universe Expand?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion clarifies how the universe can expand while being infinite, emphasizing that "expansion" refers to the increasing distances between widely separated galaxies rather than a physical increase in size from an external viewpoint. Cosmologists measure this expansion as an average rate of about 1/140 of one percent every million years. The concept of expansion applies equally to infinite and finite entities, as it is a pattern of distance growth observed from within the universe. This explanation addresses a common misconception about the nature of cosmic expansion. Understanding this perspective helps clarify the complexities of cosmological discussions.
LSulayman
Messages
42
Reaction score
0
I'm reading a lot of stuff about the expanding universe, and also about it being infinte.
So now I was wondering:
How can the universe expand while it's infinte? (or am I asking something that nobody really know's the answer to?)
 
Space news on Phys.org
LSulayman said:
...
How can the universe expand while it's infinite?

You have to understand what the cosmologists who say "expand" mean by that word.

They mean that distances between widely separated galaxies are increasing.

On average the rate of increase is currently about 1/140 of one percent every million years.


They do not mean that you could stand outside the universe and see it get bigger!

They are talking about a pattern of distance-growth seen from inside.

LSulayman said:
...
How can the universe expand while it's infinite?

An infinite thing can have that pattern of distance-growth, just as easily as a finite thing.

It is expansion seen from the inside. So the thing does not have to be finite.
 
marcus said:
You have to understand what the cosmologists who say "expand" mean by that word.

They mean that distances between widely separated galaxies are increasing.

On average the rate of increase is currently about 1/140 of one percent every million years.


They do not mean that you could stand outside the universe and see it get bigger!

They are talking about a pattern of distance-growth seen from inside.



An infinite thing can have that pattern of distance-growth, just as easily as a finite thing.

It is expansion seen from the inside. So the thing does not have to be finite.

Thank you! I actually didn't know that, nobody really explains it in all the articles I read.
 
Abstract The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has significantly advanced our ability to study black holes, achieving unprecedented spatial resolution and revealing horizon-scale structures. Notably, these observations feature a distinctive dark shadow—primarily arising from faint jet emissions—surrounded by a bright photon ring. Anticipated upgrades of the EHT promise substantial improvements in dynamic range, enabling deeper exploration of low-background regions, particularly the inner shadow...
what is the current status of the field for quantum cosmology, are there any observations that support any theory of quantum cosmology? is it just cosmology during the Planck era or does it extend past the Planck era. what are the leading candidates into research into quantum cosmology and which physics departments research it? how much respect does loop quantum cosmology has compared to string cosmology with actual cosmologists?
Back
Top