Is Your Model of Light an Effective Way to Visualize Electromagnetic Waves?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monitor16807
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Light Model
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores a conceptual model for visualizing light as an electromagnetic wave using a water analogy. In this model, the water represents the electromagnetic field, while pieces of rubber symbolize electrons that emit light, with waves generated by one piece affecting the other. Participants agree that this model effectively illustrates light as an oscillating source within the electromagnetic field, although it acknowledges limitations when applied to quantum mechanics. The conversation highlights that light behaves like a wave on a large scale, but quantum theory is necessary for understanding smaller particles. Overall, the model serves as a useful mental image for grasping the nature of light and electromagnetic waves.
Monitor16807
Messages
11
Reaction score
1
First I would like to say, I'm not that old and only know very basic things about physics i.e. Newtonian physics, also, I've not learned the maths for electromagnetic physics, so no need to try and explain it to me using that. I'm basically asking if you could tell me if I have a good model for imagining what light is.

So we have have 1 piece of rubber on a body of water, there are no waves what so ever, then someone throws a second piece of rubber on the water, this creates a wave, this wave then reaches the first piece of rubber and it starts oscillating up and down.

The water would be the electromagnetic field.
The 2 pieces of rubber would be electrons or any thing capable of emitting light.
The wave would be the light (photon?).

Remember this isn't suppose to be mathematically accurate, just a mind image.

I'm just saying light is actually the electromagnetic field (moving outwards at all time?) that just happened to have an oscillating source?

Thanks.
 
Science news on Phys.org
Newtonian physics does a poor job of modeling light. It is essentially because of this fact that modern physics has been so successful.

Electromagnetic theory is a good model as long as you're dealing with big things. Light, on a large scale looks like a wave.

When you work with smaller things like electrons, things get messy and you have to break out quantum theory.
 
Monitor16807 said:
Remember this isn't suppose to be mathematically accurate, just a mind image.

I'm just saying light is actually the electromagnetic field (moving outwards at all time?) that just happened to have an oscillating source?

Yes, it is quite a working model of light. Emitting means moving outwards, correct. But waves from other sources can reach the original source and make it move (= incident wave scattering).

Bob.
 
light is the quantum.relative equivalence of sound

There are four kinds of waves in verse fluid.
Waves that bob up and down by surface are Rayleigh waves.
The fastest travel through as p or sound or light waves.

Peace
rwj
 
One thing to note though, an electromagnetic wave is created by currents that change in time. So you need to have a moving charge(s) to have radiation.
 
Thread 'Simple math model for a Particle Image Velocimetry system'
Hello togehter, I am new to this forum and hope this post followed all the guidelines here (I tried to summarized my issue as clean as possible, two pictures are attached). I would appreciate every help: I am doing research on a Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) system. For this I want to set a simple math model for the system. I hope you can help me out. Regarding this I have 2 main Questions. 1. I am trying to find a math model which is describing what is happening in a simple Particle...
Thread 'How to model converging illumination through object plane (in ZEMAX)'
Hello community, I'm designing a projection lens system for a 35mm film projector in Zemax OpticStudio and struggling with the correct sequential mode setup for the illumination geometry. The light source is a Xenon short-arc lamp reflected by an ellipsoid mirror, which creates a converging cone with a 40.6 degree full angle that passes through the film gate. The film gate is my object plane, but the light doesn't diverge from it like a typical Lambertian source. Instead, the converging...
Back
Top