Q: How can you hear someone through a closed door?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cookies?
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Closed
AI Thread Summary
Sound can be heard through a closed door primarily because the door vibrates in response to sound waves, transferring that energy to the other side. While diffraction does play a role, especially when there are cracks or openings, the main mechanism involves the door's material interacting with sound waves. Most doors are not completely airtight, allowing some sound to pass through via vibrations. The effectiveness of sound transmission also depends on the door's material; harder surfaces transmit sound better than softer ones. Overall, both vibration and diffraction contribute to the phenomenon of hearing through a closed door.
Cookies?
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
A question about the simplest of things: Based on the physics of sound, how can you hear someone through a closed door?

I'm quite confused because someone once told me its was because the sound passes through the door; since its causing the air molecules to vibrate, when this vibration hits the door, it similarly causes the door to vibrate and transfer the sound energy through to the other side.

I've also read about diffraction as the cause so, what, is it a combination of both? Or just one. If its just diffraction, then if I was in a completely airtight room, would I then, technically, be unable to hear anything from outside?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
They were talking about diffraction when the door is cracked open slightly.

The first explanation is the correct one when the door is closed/sealed.
 
I believe both effects happen, as most doors are probably not airtight, especially the ones in houses.
 
Scenario 1: In this case, sound acts much like light in regards to the double split experiment. Sound -> crack in door. A new origin of the sound is created, and the process is repeated until the waves of sound are eventually deflected by particles in the air and the sound dissipates.

Scenario 2: In this case, sound waves interact directly with the door, causing it to vibrate. The door's vibrations create new sound waves that are similar to the ones that it was hit by. Smooth, hard, and some-what rigid objects tend to translate sound more effectively - which is why a cotton coat doesn't translate sound very well. ;)
 
Insights auto threads is broken atm, so I'm manually creating these for new Insight articles. Someone who shows interest in science is initially a welcome development. So are fresh ideas from unexpected quarters. In contrast, there is a scientific community that is meticulously organized down to the last detail, allowing little to no external influence. With the invention of social media and other sites on the internet competing for content, unprecedented opportunities have opened up for...
I am going through this course on collision detection: https://siggraphcontact.github.io/ In this link is a PDF called course notes. Scrolling down to section 1.3, called constraints. In this section it is said that we can write bilateral constraints as ##\phi(\mathbf{x}) = 0## and unilateral constraints as ##\phi(\mathbf{x}) \ge 0##. I understand that, but then it says that these constraints call also be written as: $$\mathbf{J} \mathbf{u} = 0, \mathbf{J} \mathbf{u} \ge 0,$$ where...
Back
Top