Superconducting magnet with HTS wire

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on building a superconducting magnet using thin, flat HTS wire, specifically in a pancake or flat spiral coil configuration. Participants highlight that traditional solenoid equations may not apply, emphasizing the need for a different approach based on the coil's unique geometry. Suggestions include using a simple magnetic model of a flat conductive disk with a sheet current and approximating the magnetic field based on the average radius and number of turns. Numerical methods, such as FEM with COMSOL, are recommended for complex geometries, while users are encouraged to search for specific equations related to pancake coils. The original poster is seeking to calculate the magnetic field strength along the Z-axis with defined inner and outer radii and a specific number of turns.
MagnetDude
Messages
6
Reaction score
1
Hey guys, I am building a superconducting magnet. The wire I have is extremely thin, and is flat. To put it more into perceptive it has a width and height. When I wind it into a magnet, it is more like a disk coil, or racetrack coil. Because it has a different geometry than most other electromagnets, what equation would I use to calculate its magnetic field?

Most equations I have seen are a little something like this.

p=permeability
I=current
N=Number of turns
L=length of turn

The ones I have seen are PxNxI/L.

That goes for a solenoid mainly. The length of the coil I will make, if it were to be a disk, would be the Thickness of the wire times the number of turns, its width would have nothing relevant enough do with the calculation I would assume. After I find the turn density, what do I do? It is going to be a really weird magnet.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
In most cases you end up having to use numerical methods, e.g. FEM using something like COMSOL.
Analytical methods rarely work unless you have a very simple geometry (e.g. a long solenoid(
 
The coil I think you are describing is called a “pancake” or a “flat spiral” coil.
The question as to which model to use really depends on the inner to outer radius ratio.

A simple magnetic model is a flat conductive disk with inner and outer radii that has a sheet current circulating, the sheet current is Nturns times the spiral current. That may give you a simple analytic solution.

A first approximation of the field could be that of a single turn with the average radius, multiplied by spiral current and number of turns.
 
f95toli said:
In most cases you end up having to use numerical methods, e.g. FEM using something like COMSOL.
Analytical methods rarely work unless you have a very simple geometry (e.g. a long solenoid(

F95toli: This is not a long solenoid though, this is a flat solenoid. To give you more of a perceptive of this wire, here is a link to the

Baluncore said:
The coil I think you are describing is called a “pancake” or a “flat spiral” coil.
The question as to which model to use really depends on the inner to outer radius ratio.

A simple magnetic model is a flat conductive disk with inner and outer radii that has a sheet current circulating, the sheet current is Nturns times the spiral current. That may give you a simple analytic solution.

A first approximation of the field could be that of a single turn with the average radius, multiplied by spiral current and number of turns.

I just spent about 30 minutes googling what you suggested, and that you were stating seemed to be right, but all the equations I am finding are for inductance. I am not finding anything that gives me the tesla strength of the magnetic field.
 
There are many users of pancake coils for SC magnets.
Google 'magnetic field of pancake coil' or 'magnetic field of spiral coil' and you will get examples of flat spiral design.

What are your inner and outer radii ?
Do you need axial field only ?
http://spectronet.de/portals/visqua/story_docs/vortraege_2009/090520_measurement/090520_tag1/090520_03_andris.pdf
 
Last edited:
Baluncore said:
There are many users of pancake coils for SC magnets.
Google 'magnetic field of pancake coil' or 'magnetic field of spiral coil' and you will get examples of flat spiral design.

What are your inner and outer radii ?
Do you need axial field only ?
http://spectronet.de/portals/visqua/story_docs/vortraege_2009/090520_measurement/090520_tag1/090520_03_andris.pdf
Sorry for the late reply. I am only trying to fine the field that would come out of the Z axis if that is what you mean by axial field. my inner radii is .7535 CM, my outer is going to be 1.691, with 75 turns of HTS wire. I think Ill be able to do all the calculations myself, My math skills might not be that sharp for I am still in high school. I have heard the term vector before, but I forgot what it is for.
 
I used to be an HVAC technician. One time I had a service call in which there was no power to the thermostat. The thermostat did not have power because the fuse in the air handler was blown. The fuse in the air handler was blown because there was a low voltage short. The rubber coating on one of the thermostat wires was chewed off by a rodent. The exposed metal in the thermostat wire was touching the metal cabinet of the air handler. This was a low voltage short. This low voltage...
Hey guys. I have a question related to electricity and alternating current. Say an alien fictional society developed electricity, and settled on a standard like 73V AC current at 46 Hz. How would appliances be designed, and what impact would the lower frequency and voltage have on transformers, wiring, TVs, computers, LEDs, motors, and heating, assuming the laws of physics and technology are the same as on Earth?
Thread 'How Does Jaguar's 1980s V12 Dual Coil Ignition System Enhance Spark Strength?'
I have come across a dual coil ignition system as used by Jaguar on their V12 in the 1980's. It uses two ignition coils with their primary windings wired in parallel. The primary coil has its secondary winding wired to the distributor and then to the spark plugs as is standard practice. However, the auxiliary coil has it secondary winding output sealed off. The purpose of the system was to provide a stronger spark to the plugs, always a difficult task with the very short dwell time of a...
Back
Top