B What is Olbers' Paradox and how does it relate to the universe's structure?

AI Thread Summary
Olbers' Paradox explores why the night sky is dark despite the vast number of stars in an infinite universe. The discussion highlights the relationship between a star's brightness, its surface area, and the distribution of stars in a spherical shell. The confusion arises from the use of the same variable 'r' for both the radius of the shell and the average radius of stars, which complicates the integration of luminosity. It is clarified that energy from a star spreads over a sphere with radius equal to the distance from the star, supporting the paradox's conclusion that total luminosity diverges to infinity in a static universe. Ultimately, the discussion resolves the confusion about the variables used in the calculations.
alejandromeira
Messages
82
Reaction score
15
I'm beginning to study the Matt Roots book Introduction to Cosmology and in the section 1.3 Olbers' Paradox he writes:
"If the surface area of an average star is A, then its brightness is B=L/A. The sun may be taken to be such an average star, mainly because we know it so well.
The number of stars in a spherical shell of radius r and thickness dr is then ##4\pi r²ndr##. Their total radiation as observed at the origin of a static universe of infinite extent is then found by integrating the spherical shells from 0 to ##\infty##:"
$$\int_{0}^\infty 4\pi r^2nBdr = \int_{0}^\infty nLdr = \infty$$
______________________________________________

I suppose that he use ##B=\frac{L}{4\pi r^2} ## for obtain the second integral, but r is the radius of the shell not the average radius of the stars. I'm a little bit confused whit that.

Of course if the Universe is infinite and the integration runs from 0 to infinity the total luminosity must be infinity.

My doubt is about the use of r above, in the radius of shell and also the same letter for the radius of a star... and then vanishing...:oldconfused::oldconfused::oldconfused: I'm a little bit confused.

 
Space news on Phys.org
##A## should be the area of a sphere with radius equal to the distance to the star. This is because the energy flux from the star is assumed to be evenly spread over that sphere.
 
Ok. it is understood. Also just after your answer I was thinking that the energy that we receive from a star a distance r, must be spreaded in a sphere of radius r.
Ok thanks a lot! :oldsmile::oldsmile: Thread solved.
 
Abstract The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has significantly advanced our ability to study black holes, achieving unprecedented spatial resolution and revealing horizon-scale structures. Notably, these observations feature a distinctive dark shadow—primarily arising from faint jet emissions—surrounded by a bright photon ring. Anticipated upgrades of the EHT promise substantial improvements in dynamic range, enabling deeper exploration of low-background regions, particularly the inner shadow...
Back
Top