- #2,626
dkotschessaa
- 1,060
- 783
SW VandeCarr said:Well, there's no questioning her technical virtuosity and, for the most part, I enjoyed her interpretation. But maybe you could explain to me why talented jazz musicians, mostly pianists, like to throw in such harsh dissonant chords and break the rhythmic flow. Is it to shock, or maybe wake up the audience? Brubeck used do that too. Only Thelonious Monk could do that and make it work, IMHO.
Jazz can be a bit like a drug. People that listen to a lot of it often start looking for "stronger stuff." I like a lot of dissonance and I like tricky rhythms, but only if they fit into the musical structure. In this case, I wouldn't say the rhythmic flow is "broken." But it does take a bit of sophistication to understand in what way the rhythm is being played with. Same with the chords.
-Dave K
(also a jazz musician)