What is the edge of the universe and what lies beyond?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Stephanus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Edge Universe
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of the universe's edge and the nature of its dimensions. Participants explore whether the universe could be closed, allowing for a return to the starting point if one travels in a specific direction. They emphasize that the observable universe does not have a known edge and that galaxies beyond our observable limits may still exist, adhering to Hubble's law despite being too distant for us to see. The conversation also touches on the idea that the Big Bang occurred everywhere simultaneously, implying that all galaxies, including those beyond our observable universe, originated from this event. Ultimately, the nature of the universe's shape—whether closed, open, or flat—remains uncertain.
Stephanus
Messages
1,316
Reaction score
104
Dear PF Forum,
I have a simple and cliche question.
What is the edge of the universe?

1. We live on the surface of the earth. It's 2 dimensions against Earth 3 dimensions.
If we start from Equador which lies on the equator to the east, we'll reach Columbia then Brazil then Atlantic ocean, continue on then Congo, then Kenya, then Indian Ocean, across Maldives then, my country Indonesia (the only Asian nation in equator :smile:) then go on to the east, Papua, then Pacific ocean, then some small islands in Pacific, continue on then we arrive back to Equador.
Does the universe look like that? 3 dimensions against 4 dimensions. So if we travel "east" from earth, we'll go back to Earth again?

2. Consider this simple drawing
B <-------- 46 gly ------------ Earth ---------------- 46gly -------------> A
If we travel east from Earth and on and on, and we reach Galaxy A, 46 giga light year "east" from eart.
What would that be?
Earth ----------------- 46 gly ------------------> A ------------------->?
Can we reach back to B?
Earth ----------------- 46 gly ------------------> A ------------------ n distance ----> B

3. Or this model
I choose 46 gly because it's the time of big bag adjusted by Hubble law.
B <-------- 46 gly ------------ Earth ---------------- 46gly -------------> A
Earth ---------------- 46gly -------------> A --------------- 46 gly -------------> C
A --------------- 46 gly -------------> C ---------------- 46gly -------------> D
C ---------------- 46gly -------------> D ---------------- 46gly -------------> E
And no end of it?

If we come up 46 gly by the age of the universe 13.8 billions light year adjusted by Hubble law,
4. Are there any galaxies beyond A to the "east"?
5. Supposed there are galaxies beyond A that we can't see. Are the distance of those galaxies still conform with Hubble law, but they are already too fast that we can't see their light?
6. If there are other galaxies beyond A to the "east", did they come from "our" big bang?

Thanks for any answer to fullfill my curiousity.
 
Space news on Phys.org
Stephanus said:
Does the universe look like that? 3 dimensions against 4 dimensions. So if we travel "east" from earth, we'll go back to Earth again?
There is no known answer to this question. As far as we know, there is no higher dimensional space.

Stephanus said:
B <-------- 46 gly ------------ Earth ---------------- 46gly -------------> A

You are here talking about the observable universe. There is no indication that the Universe should do anything but continue on outside of that. Of course, there is no way of knowing that.

Stephanus said:
but they are already too fast that we can't see their light?
It is not about the galaxies moving, it is about space expanding.

Stephanus said:
If there are other galaxies beyond A to the "east", did they come from "our" big bang?
According to the standard model of cosmology at the present time, the big bang happened everywhere in the universe at once.
 
  • Like
Likes Stephanus
Stephanus said:
What is the edge of the universe?

There is no known edge to the universe.

Stephanus said:
Does the universe look like that? 3 dimensions against 4 dimensions. So if we travel "east" from earth, we'll go back to Earth again?

We don't know. It is certainly possible that the shape of the universe leads to a 'closed' universe, where traveling in one direction eventually causes you to loop back around to your starting point, but it could just as likely be that the universe is either 'open' or 'flat', both of which may mean the universe is infinite in size. Note that even a universe that is closed is not required to be embedded within a 4th spatial dimension. There is a difference between extrensic curvature (measured with respect to a higher dimension) and intrinsic curvature (measured within existing spatial dimensions).

See here for more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_of_the_universe

Stephanus said:
2. Consider this simple drawing
B <-------- 46 gly ------------ Earth ---------------- 46gly -------------> A
If we travel east from Earth and on and on, and we reach Galaxy A, 46 giga light year "east" from eart.
What would that be?

As you said, it would be a galaxy.

Stephanus said:
6. If there are other galaxies beyond A to the "east", did they come from "our" big bang?

Yes they did.
 
  • Like
Likes Stephanus
Orodruin said:
According to the standard model of cosmology at the present time, the big bang happened everywhere in the universe at once.
According to the standard model of cosmology at the present time, the big bang happened everywhere in the universe at once.
I don't mean to be picky, but... is that quote modification alright with you?
 
OCR said:
I don't mean to be picky, but... is that quote modification alright with you?
That makes sense, at least for me.:smile:
 
Abstract The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has significantly advanced our ability to study black holes, achieving unprecedented spatial resolution and revealing horizon-scale structures. Notably, these observations feature a distinctive dark shadow—primarily arising from faint jet emissions—surrounded by a bright photon ring. Anticipated upgrades of the EHT promise substantial improvements in dynamic range, enabling deeper exploration of low-background regions, particularly the inner shadow...
what is the current status of the field for quantum cosmology, are there any observations that support any theory of quantum cosmology? is it just cosmology during the Planck era or does it extend past the Planck era. what are the leading candidates into research into quantum cosmology and which physics departments research it? how much respect does loop quantum cosmology has compared to string cosmology with actual cosmologists?
Back
Top