What is the largest organelle in a plant cell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Titania
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Cell
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the question of which organelle is the largest in a cell, with a focus on the nucleus and vacuole. It highlights that the largest organelle can vary depending on the type of cell. For instance, red blood cells lack a nucleus, making it irrelevant in that context. In liver cells, the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) can occupy more volume than the nucleus. The conversation acknowledges the diversity of cells, particularly in plants, where the vacuole is often depicted as the largest organelle. However, it is generally accepted that the nucleus is the largest single organelle in most cells. The discussion also points out that terms like "largest" can be misleading in biology due to the complexity of cell structures, including multinucleate cells and unique organisms like fungi and giant single-celled algae. Overall, while the nucleus is commonly cited as the largest organelle, the endoplasmic reticulum can also be significant in certain contexts.
Titania
Messages
11
Reaction score
1
It is said that nucleus is the largest organelle in the cell. (Well, it doesn't really specify.) So, I'm actually wondering about the vacuole. Isnt it drawn the largest in plant cell? I did manage to find some information from internet but I am not really satisfied. :3
No offence, just say what you think is right. I want to learn more. Thanks in advance~
 
Biology news on Phys.org
Which organelle is the largest probably depends on the type of cell being studied. For example, red blood cells do not contain a nucleus, so obviously the nucleus would not be the largest organelle for those cells. In the case of a typical hepatocyte (liver cell), the endoplasmic reticulum may take up more volume (~16% of the cell volume) than the nucleus (~6% of the cell volume): http://book.bionumbers.org/how-big-is-the-endoplasmic-reticulum-of-cells/
 
Ehh, arent they just found abundantly, not the largest? Do correct me.
 
The ER is a single continuous structure.
 
There many kinds of cells, sometimes asking for the 'largest' organelle does not make a lot of sense. Why? Because of the diversity of cells, especially in plants:
The largest relative volume of a single organelle (what @Ygggdrasil answered ) is a way to provide a kind of answer. This varies across tissues in animals and plants as well.
Most times the answer is: Usually the largest single organelle in a cell is the nucleus. In both plant and animals.
If this if for HS biology, then go with what you have in the post above, but be aware of the weirdness in the world of cells.

Really there is no one perfect answer, you always find something goofy:
Multinucleate cells - one cell, many nuclei, relative volume of nuclear material is high. Does this count?
Fungal hyphae (Basidiomyces) - kind of like the root body of some fungi like mushrooms - are mutlinucleate, but also have huge amounts of ER.
Acetabularia is a GIGANTIC single cell (3 inches high sometimes), so the is the ER the largest? (These things are just plain wonderful).
2000px-Acetabularia_mediterranea_life.svg.png
 
  • Like
Likes Hoophy and Titania
Back
Top