What is the largest size for identical particles?

  • Thread starter scope
  • Start date
In summary, the concept of identical particles applies to fundamental particles and their combinations, but breaks down at larger scales due to variations and imperfections. It is possible for two identical objects to exist, but only if they are in the same quantum state. Researchers strive to create macro-scale substances that are virtually flaw-free, but this remains a challenge in materials science.
  • #1
scope
61
0
hi,

I would like to know how big can be 2 identical particles?
can they be atoms, molecules, or even much larger than this?

in the extreme case, can they be 2 identical cars for example?

can we also say that any 2 electrons in the universe are identical particles?

I would be grateful for your reply!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Your question is a little confusing. However on the particle level, any 2 particles of the same kind are identical. When it comes to atoms, etc. these are combinations. As long as the constituents are the same, they are identical. However at the molecular level things get more complicated, since arrangements matter.
 
  • #3
scope said:
can we also say that any 2 electrons in the universe are identical particles?

In regards to this part of your question, I think there is a quote from David Griffith's (or was it Schroeder) that I'll paraphrase:

It does not make sense to talk about this electron or that electron. The best we can do is talk about an electron.

All fundamental particles one anyone type are entirely indistinguishable from one another. There is no way to "mark" one electron to set it apart from the others.
 
  • #4
scope said:
in the extreme case, can they be 2 identical cars for example
Yes, provided they are in the same "quantum state".
 
  • #5
scope said:
in the extreme case, can they be 2 identical cars for example?
The identicality of a substance breaks down pretty quickly before even you get out of microscopic scales.

Even crystals, the most highly ordered of macro objects, are full of flaws at the microscopic level. And regular materials such as even the thinnest of metals are much more disordered than the most disordered crystals.

It is the Holy Grail of Materials Science to produce macro-scale substances that are virtually flaw-free.
 

FAQ: What is the largest size for identical particles?

What is the concept of "size of identical particles"?

The size of identical particles refers to the physical dimensions of particles that are identical in terms of their chemical composition and structure.

How is the size of identical particles determined?

The size of identical particles can be determined through various techniques such as microscopy, spectroscopy, and particle size analysis methods.

What factors can affect the size of identical particles?

The size of identical particles can be affected by factors such as temperature, pressure, and the presence of other substances in their environment.

Why is it important to understand the size of identical particles?

Understanding the size of identical particles is important in fields such as materials science, environmental science, and pharmaceuticals, as it can affect their properties and behavior.

Can the size of identical particles change?

Yes, the size of identical particles can change due to external factors such as physical or chemical processes, or internal factors such as aging or degradation.

Similar threads

Replies
38
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
36
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
2K
Back
Top