- #1
AnOpenMind
Does anyone know a physics forum where theory discussion is allowed? My first post was deleted by a mod for trying to discuss ideas.
Where Can Scientists Discuss Physics Theories Online?
- Thread starter AnOpenMind
- Start date
-
- Tags
- Discussion Theory
In summary, the conversation discusses the search for a physics forum where theory discussion is allowed after the original poster's first post was deleted by a moderator. The conversation also touches on the rules and guidelines of Physicsforums.com and suggests alternative forums for speculative discussions. The conversation ends with a reminder to focus on asking questions rather than proposing answers and to be mindful of existing scientific evidence.
- #2
- 22,183
- 3,325
You're just looking for trouble now, aren't you??
- #3
- 32,820
- 4,720
AnOpenMind said:
It was deleted not because you wanted to do a "theory discussion", but rather you wanted to do a speculative theory discussion. There's a difference.
Please re-read the PF Rules. In particular, this part:
This applies throughout this forum.
Zz.
- #4
AnOpenMind
Yes I understood the first time you said it. That's why it hasn't happened again.
- #5
AnOpenMind
micromass said:
No. I'm looking for a discussion of a specific topic.
- #6
- 22,183
- 3,325
AnOpenMind said:
A discussion about what? About which forums do allow speculative posts? Well, do a quick google search for physics forums and see what pops up! There are a lot of physics forums around! (none of them is as good as PF though
)Maybe try http://www.sciforums.com/
- #7
AnOpenMind
micromass said:
I'm not permitted to say here. If someone can suggest a good forum in which to talk about it, I'd be happy to explain.
- #8
- 22,183
- 3,325
AnOpenMind said:
Like I said, do a quick google search: http://www.google.be/#sclient=psy&h...c.r_pw.&fp=823b6a7917ab7124&biw=1366&bih=645"
Or go to the sciforums I linked. Such a stuff is permissable there.
Last edited by a moderator:
- #9
AnOpenMind
Thank you very much sir. Yes I'm already there now having a look, as I should have pointed out. I came across PhysForum and am checking there as well. I apologize for any trouble caused by me posting certain types of ideas.
- #10
Ms Music
- 119
- 1
Ugh. Both sciforums and physforum are pond scum.
- #11
TurtleMeister
- 896
- 98
This site: http://www.bautforum.com/index.php, has a sub forum called ATM, "against the mainstream", where you can present your theory.
- #12
Chi Meson
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 1,894
- 11
You mean "theory" . The quotes are necessary, because actual, repeatable, confirmable data are necessary in order to have a theory. OP has a speculation.TurtleMeister said:
- #13
Pythagorean
Gold Member
- 4,409
- 321
AnOpenMind said:
physicsforums.com
Don't be so dramatic. You're not allowed to speculate. You can say "I speculated about [..]" because that sentence in itself is not speculation.
- #14
Pengwuino
Gold Member
- 5,123
- 20
- #15
Astronuc
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2023 Award
- 22,195
- 6,878
Pengwuino said:
- #16
kcajrenreb
- 49
- 0
Stay here, I'm sure you'll like it better. Just be sure to look over your posts and ensure thet follow all of the forum guidelines. Without those rules, this forum would be a mess of speculations, and stuff of the sort.
If you really need to speculate, then do so, but keep it to yourself, and consider it wrong, as you do not have a proper mathematical understanding of the subject (I'm assuming). I'm not trying to be unfriendly, I'm trying to tell the truth.
If you really need to speculate, then do so, but keep it to yourself, and consider it wrong, as you do not have a proper mathematical understanding of the subject (I'm assuming). I'm not trying to be unfriendly, I'm trying to tell the truth.
- #17
Ryan_m_b
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
- 5,963
- 723
AnOpenMind said:
There really is no need to go elsewhere, what you can do here at PF is far better than any website where people discuss speculation. Simply ask questions rather than propose answers. E.g
Instead of...
New User said:
...one should say
Then you and everyone else who is eager to learn can find out! Remember any idea you come up with probably touches on subjects that have already been thoroughly investigated.New User said:
- #18
Evo
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
- 24,017
- 3,339
Excellent response Ryna! And a perfect place to end.
FAQ: Where Can Scientists Discuss Physics Theories Online?
What is a theory discussion?
A theory discussion is a conversation or debate about a scientific theory, which is a well-established explanation of a natural phenomenon based on extensive evidence and experimentation.
Why are theory discussions important in science?
Theory discussions are important because they allow scientists to critically evaluate and refine existing theories, as well as propose new ones. This process leads to a deeper understanding of the natural world and drives scientific progress.
How do scientists engage in theory discussions?
Scientists engage in theory discussions by presenting evidence, data, and arguments to support or challenge a theory. They also consider alternative explanations and collaborate with other experts in the field to reach a consensus.
Are theory discussions always productive?
No, theory discussions can sometimes become heated or mired in personal opinions rather than scientific evidence. However, when conducted in a respectful and evidence-based manner, theory discussions can lead to valuable insights and advancements in scientific understanding.
Can non-scientists participate in theory discussions?
Yes, non-scientists can participate in theory discussions by learning about the topic and contributing their perspectives and questions. However, it is important to defer to the expertise of scientists and rely on evidence rather than personal beliefs or opinions.