Why are metals in aqueous solution basic, and non-metals acidic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter adf89812
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Aqueous Metals
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concepts of proton acceptors and lone pair donors within acid-base theory, particularly in relation to metals and non-metals in water. It is noted that metals, being less electronegative than non-metals, tend to donate electrons to hydrogen in water, leading to the release of hydrogen ions (protons) as hydrogen separates from oxygen. In contrast, non-metals, which are more electronegative, form larger acid molecules by attracting electrons from water without releasing them, resulting in a structure where hydrogen is the least electronegative atom, potentially leading to the formation of protons. The conversation emphasizes the need for clearer explanations and specific references to support these claims, as vague assertions are not deemed acceptable in the forum.
adf89812
Messages
37
Reaction score
1
TL;DR Summary
Why are metals in aqueous solution basic, and non-metals in water acidic?
I heard an explanation about something being a better proton acceptor or lone pair donor but that doesn't make sense. I couldn't explain in in terms of acid-base theory.

The hand-waving way I saw it was that metals are less electronegative than non-metals, so in water, they'll donate their electron to the hydrogen, the hydrogen will break away from the oxygen because hydrogen hates oxygen hogging its electrons, and because hydrogen electronegative enough.

With non-metals, my hand-waving is that metals are more electronegative, when they bond with water, they'll just form one bigger molecule because they suck on other's electrons without letting go and form one big acid molecule where the least electronegative thing in there is a hydrogen, which falls of into a proton, and it may or may not be polyprotic.
 
Last edited:
Chemistry news on Phys.org
adf89812 said:
I heard

adf89812 said:
The hand-waving way I saw it
These vague "citations" are not acceptable here on PF. Please post exactly what you heard/saw.
 
Thread 'How to make Sodium Chlorate by Electrolysis of salt water?'
I have a power supply for electrolysis of salt water brine, variable 3v to 6v up to 30 amps. Cathode is stainless steel, anode is carbon rods. Carbon rod surface area 42" sq. the Stainless steel cathode should be 21" sq. Salt is pure 100% salt dissolved into distilled water. I have been making saturated salt wrong. Today I learn saturated salt is, dissolve pure salt into 150°f water cool to 100°f pour into the 2 gallon brine tank. I find conflicting information about brine tank...
Engineers slash iridium use in electrolyzer catalyst by 80%, boosting path to affordable green hydrogen https://news.rice.edu/news/2025/engineers-slash-iridium-use-electrolyzer-catalyst-80-boosting-path-affordable-green Ruthenium is also fairly expensive (a year ago it was about $490/ troy oz, but has nearly doubled in price over the past year, now about $910/ troy oz). I tracks prices of Pt, Pd, Ru, Ir and Ru. Of the 5 metals, rhodium (Rh) is the most expensive. A year ago, Rh and Ir...
Back
Top