- #211
Moonbear
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 11,924
- 54
People usually distinguish between smashed potatoes (the lumpy ones) and whipped potatoes (the smooth ones). I like them lumpy only if there's other stuff in them, like garlic and onions...and then I call them dirty mashed potatoes. But, when they are whipped, I really can't tell the difference no matter what kind of potato I used. I've never had a mashed potato I would call "gluey." Maybe you're not adding enough milk or butter? I don't have a fixed amount of either of those, just adjust it as needed until the potatoes are the right consistency of fluffy. What I really don't understand are people who make mashed potatoes with water instead of milk and butter. They're just runny boiled potatoes.Evo said:just like it has become popular today to have lumpy potatoes instead of the original, smooth, lumpless recipe.