- #841
zoobyshoe
- 6,510
- 1,291
One Snopes author is highly skeptical this could ever have worked:1oldman2 said:Seems it was possible that while buying a piglet (packaged in a bag of course) at ye old village market it was a scam to substitute a cat for the piglet. at least that's one of many explanations I came across while researching my post
http://www.snopes.com/language/phrases/catbag.asp
However, to become a famous scam, it really only needed to have been tried.
I also question the Snope's author's assumption that the "pig" must have been sold live. If the vendor's cry was, "Pigs in a poke! Slaughtered just this morning!" then it would be much harder to tell you had a cat in a bag.