Sign of Work (Negative or Positive)

  • #1
Ineedhelpwithphysics
43
7
Homework Statement
A pump is required to lift 850 kg
of water per minute from a well 14.7 m
deep and eject it with a speed of 17.7 m/s
Relevant Equations
W = F*d
W = delta KE
Im confused I did

850*9.8*14.7 = 1.2x10^5

Why is it not negative since the force is opposite to the motion?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The force that the pump exerts on the water is upward, and the motion is upward.
 
  • Like
Likes PeroK
  • #3
What exactly is the question as was given to you? Which work are you trying to calculate? When calculating work you have to specify the force that does the work and the system on which this work is done.

Assuming that the system is the water, the pump does positive work on the water as @Chestermiller explained but gravity does negative work on the water. In any case, in the work-energy theorem equation that you wrote down, W is the net work done on the water, that is the positive work done by the pump and the negative work done by gravity. You just calculated the work done by gravity with the wrong sign.
 
  • #4
Ineedhelpwithphysics said:
Homework Statement: A pump is required to lift 850 kg
of water per minute from a well 14.7 m
deep and eject it with a speed of 17.7 m/s
Relevant Equations: W = F*d
W = delta KE

Im confused I did

850*9.8*14.7 = 1.2x10^5

Why is it not negative since the force is opposite to the motion?
You can't get a negative number by multiplying positive numbers. Your equation represents force and displacement in the same direction. The force is positive and the displacement is positive.
 
  • #5
Sign of what work? Always state the full question exactly as given. In this case it could be either the work done by the pump or the work done by gravity. If you don’t specify, we cannot know.
 

FAQ: Sign of Work (Negative or Positive)

What does a positive sign of work indicate in physics?

A positive sign of work indicates that the force applied to an object is in the same direction as the object's displacement. This means that energy is being transferred to the object, causing it to move or accelerate in the direction of the force.

What does a negative sign of work indicate in physics?

A negative sign of work indicates that the force applied to an object is in the opposite direction to the object's displacement. This means that energy is being taken away from the object, often causing it to slow down or decelerate.

How is the sign of work determined in a physical system?

The sign of work is determined by the angle between the force vector and the displacement vector. If the angle is less than 90 degrees, the work is positive. If the angle is greater than 90 degrees, the work is negative. If the angle is exactly 90 degrees, no work is done.

Can the sign of work be zero, and what does it signify?

Yes, the sign of work can be zero. This occurs when the force applied is perpendicular to the direction of displacement, meaning no work is done. An example of this is when an object moves in a circular path under a centripetal force; the force is perpendicular to the displacement, resulting in zero work.

Why is the concept of the sign of work important in physics?

The concept of the sign of work is important because it helps in understanding how energy is transferred within a system. Positive work indicates energy input, while negative work indicates energy removal. This understanding is crucial for analyzing and predicting the behavior of physical systems in various applications, from simple mechanics to complex thermodynamics.

Similar threads

Back
Top