- #176
Stavros Kiri
- 1,082
- 898
A) Still for Oct 30, 2021:
Yes, finally it was a slowly rising tendency (both for speed and proton density) that continued all day yesterday (today is Oct 31), with speed exceeding 350Km/sec, even exceeded 400Km/sec etc. ..., and continued [rising tendency etc.] even until today, with a max (around the time when the CME arrived - after all it was a weak impact - see ahead) of 458Km/sec at ~11:30UT ...
However, it seems that the initial rising tendency [see previous post yesterday etc.] (and especially the rising in the proton density, accompanied with smooth slowly rising of speed etc.) etc. may have been due to a different phenomenon and not due to the arrival of the CME yet at that point (see ahead) ...
These are from yesterday:
E.g.
" Solar wind
speed: 387.3 km/sec
density: 5.7 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2319 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: C1 2129 UT Oct30
24-hr: C3 0315 UT Oct30
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2350 UT
Daily Sun: 30 Oct 21
Expand: labels | no labels
Sunspot AR2887 has a 'beta-gamma' magnetic field that harbors energy for strong M-class and X-class solar flares. Credit: SDO/HMI "
" GEOMAGNETIC STORM UPDATE: We're still waiting for the CME. Right now minor geomagnetic unrest is happening at Arctic latitudes. This is due to a crack that opened in Earth's magnetic field--a phenomenon unrelated to the incoming CME. So far the much-anticipated storm has not yet begun. Subscribers to ourSpace Weather Alert Service will receive a text message when the CME strikes.
MODELLING THE CORONAL MASS EJECTION--UPDATED: NOAA forecasters have a sophisticated computer program called "WSA-ENLIL," which models the propagation of CMEs through interplanetary space. Here is the latest model for the CME now approaching Earth:
If these images confuse you, here is a labeled frame to help make sense of it.
The computer model predicts that the CME will make first contact with our planet around 1800 UT on Oct. 30th. That time has already passed, so the CME must be moving more slowly than forecasters thought. A slower moving-CME could deliver a weaker blow, and thus a less intense storm.
The model also predicts a sharp increase in solar wind speed (800 km/s) and a 5-fold jump in solar wind density in the CME's wake. Such conditions, if they materialize, could still fuel a potent storm despite the CME's tardy arrival.
Our revised forecast calls for G2 or G3 conditions during the early hours of Oct. 31st. Happy Halloween! "B) Today Oct 31, 2021:
1) [from spaceweather.com]
" WEAK CME IMPACT: A CME hit Earth's magnetic field on Oct. 31st at approximately 10:00 UT. The impact was weak--a far cry from the "big hit" we expected. What happened? It's possible that the bulk of the Oct. 28th CME missed our planet; after all, it was directed somewhat south of the sun-Earth line. Despite the feebleness of the impact, minor G1-class geomagnetic storms are still possible in the hours ahead. (...)
AURORAS OVER ICELAND: Last night (Oct. 30th) on the south coast of Iceland, Christopher Mathews was waiting for the CME to arrive when, suddenly, the sky filled with auroras:
"The rock formation just offshore is all that remains of an extinct volcano eroded by North Atlantic waves," says Mathews, who took the picture from the Reykjanes Peninsula.
Spoiler alert: This was not the big CME everyone was waiting for. Instead, Mathews may have observed the near-miss of a different CME, a minor cloud which left the sun on Oct. 26th. It was expected to pass close to Earth on Oct. 30th--and apparently it did. A ripple in the solar wind from the nearby CME disturbed Earth's magnetic field, sparking auroras over Iceland and Scandinavia. "
2) Latest watch:
E.g.
" Solar wind
speed: 428.4 km/sec
density: 12.4 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1457 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B4 0923 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 1529 UT Oct30
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1500 UT
Daily Sun: 31 Oct 21
Expand: labels | no labels
A new and active sunspot is emerging at the circled location. Credit: SDO/HMI "
And
" Solar wind
speed: 434.5 km/sec
density: 12.3 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1506 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B4 0923 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 1529 UT Oct30
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1510 UT "
...
" Solar wind
speed: 433.6 km/sec
density: 12.0 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1545 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B4 0955 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 0706 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1550 UT "
And just before closing:
" Solar wind
speed: 423.0 km/sec
density: 11.9 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1616 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B6 1615 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 0706 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1620 UT "
And
" Solar wind
speed: 420.7 km/sec
density: 11.5 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1620 UT
...
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B6 1615 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 0706 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1625 UT "
...
[Showing a perhaps dropping tendency at this point, as if the main part of storms or of the phenomenon is passing ... (we'll see) ]
[Radio interference, perhaps mainly low to mild, was seen with above earlier speeds etc. ...]
P.S.
1) And a later look:
" Solar wind
speed: 412.6 km/sec
density: 9.3 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2030 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: C3 2000 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 2000 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2035 UT "
And
" Solar wind
speed: 405.9 km/sec
density: 7.7 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2046 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: C3 2000 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 2000 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2050 UT "
+ rising again (!?) ... (or temporary? ...) :
" Solar wind
speed: 435.0 km/sec
density: 8.9 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2056 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: C3 2000 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 2000 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2100 UT "
...
2) Latest description from spaceweather.com (and kind of apologetic ...):
" WEAK CME IMPACT AND GEOMAGNETIC STORM: A CME hit Earth's magnetic field on Oct. 31st at ~10:00 UT. The impact was weak--a far cry from the "big hit" we expected--and it sparked an equally weak G1-class geomagnetic storm.
In Alberta, Canada, photographer Harlan Thomas stayed up all night waiting for the predicted strong geomagnetic storm. Instead, he caught this lesser display just before sunrise over icy Dewitt Pond:
"It was a short-lived event," says Thomas. "The auroras were active and battled the twilight until about 45 minutes before the sun came up."
In summary, the Halloween Storm of 2021 was more trick than treat. What happened? It's possible that the bulk of the Oct. 28th CME simply missed our planet. The source of the CME, sunspot AR2887, is located in the sun's southern hemisphere. When it exploded 3 days ago, much of the debris flew south of the sun-Earth line. Computer models suggesting a direct hit apparently gave too little weight to the CME's assymetry.
Hey, it happens! Space weather forecasting is a probabilistic activity beset by the unknowns of storms that get started 93 million miles away from Earth and glide for days invisibly through the near vacuum of interplanetary space before they spring upon us with little warning. May be next time... "
Yes, finally it was a slowly rising tendency (both for speed and proton density) that continued all day yesterday (today is Oct 31), with speed exceeding 350Km/sec, even exceeded 400Km/sec etc. ..., and continued [rising tendency etc.] even until today, with a max (around the time when the CME arrived - after all it was a weak impact - see ahead) of 458Km/sec at ~11:30UT ...
However, it seems that the initial rising tendency [see previous post yesterday etc.] (and especially the rising in the proton density, accompanied with smooth slowly rising of speed etc.) etc. may have been due to a different phenomenon and not due to the arrival of the CME yet at that point (see ahead) ...
These are from yesterday:
E.g.
" Solar wind
speed: 387.3 km/sec
density: 5.7 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2319 UT
|
6-hr max: C1 2129 UT Oct30
24-hr: C3 0315 UT Oct30
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2350 UT
Expand: labels | no labels
" GEOMAGNETIC STORM UPDATE: We're still waiting for the CME. Right now minor geomagnetic unrest is happening at Arctic latitudes. This is due to a crack that opened in Earth's magnetic field--a phenomenon unrelated to the incoming CME. So far the much-anticipated storm has not yet begun. Subscribers to ourSpace Weather Alert Service will receive a text message when the CME strikes.
MODELLING THE CORONAL MASS EJECTION--UPDATED: NOAA forecasters have a sophisticated computer program called "WSA-ENLIL," which models the propagation of CMEs through interplanetary space. Here is the latest model for the CME now approaching Earth:
If these images confuse you, here is a labeled frame to help make sense of it.
The computer model predicts that the CME will make first contact with our planet around 1800 UT on Oct. 30th. That time has already passed, so the CME must be moving more slowly than forecasters thought. A slower moving-CME could deliver a weaker blow, and thus a less intense storm.
The model also predicts a sharp increase in solar wind speed (800 km/s) and a 5-fold jump in solar wind density in the CME's wake. Such conditions, if they materialize, could still fuel a potent storm despite the CME's tardy arrival.
Our revised forecast calls for G2 or G3 conditions during the early hours of Oct. 31st. Happy Halloween! "B) Today Oct 31, 2021:
1) [from spaceweather.com]
" WEAK CME IMPACT: A CME hit Earth's magnetic field on Oct. 31st at approximately 10:00 UT. The impact was weak--a far cry from the "big hit" we expected. What happened? It's possible that the bulk of the Oct. 28th CME missed our planet; after all, it was directed somewhat south of the sun-Earth line. Despite the feebleness of the impact, minor G1-class geomagnetic storms are still possible in the hours ahead. (...)
AURORAS OVER ICELAND: Last night (Oct. 30th) on the south coast of Iceland, Christopher Mathews was waiting for the CME to arrive when, suddenly, the sky filled with auroras:
"The rock formation just offshore is all that remains of an extinct volcano eroded by North Atlantic waves," says Mathews, who took the picture from the Reykjanes Peninsula.
Spoiler alert: This was not the big CME everyone was waiting for. Instead, Mathews may have observed the near-miss of a different CME, a minor cloud which left the sun on Oct. 26th. It was expected to pass close to Earth on Oct. 30th--and apparently it did. A ripple in the solar wind from the nearby CME disturbed Earth's magnetic field, sparking auroras over Iceland and Scandinavia. "
2) Latest watch:
E.g.
" Solar wind
speed: 428.4 km/sec
density: 12.4 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1457 UT
6-hr max: B4 0923 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 1529 UT Oct30
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1500 UT
Expand: labels | no labels
And
" Solar wind
speed: 434.5 km/sec
density: 12.3 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1506 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B4 0923 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 1529 UT Oct30
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1510 UT "
...
" Solar wind
speed: 433.6 km/sec
density: 12.0 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1545 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B4 0955 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 0706 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1550 UT "
And just before closing:
" Solar wind
speed: 423.0 km/sec
density: 11.9 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1616 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B6 1615 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 0706 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1620 UT "
And
" Solar wind
speed: 420.7 km/sec
density: 11.5 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 1620 UT
...
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: B6 1615 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 0706 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 1625 UT "
...
[Showing a perhaps dropping tendency at this point, as if the main part of storms or of the phenomenon is passing ... (we'll see) ]
[Radio interference, perhaps mainly low to mild, was seen with above earlier speeds etc. ...]
P.S.
1) And a later look:
" Solar wind
speed: 412.6 km/sec
density: 9.3 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2030 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: C3 2000 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 2000 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2035 UT "
And
" Solar wind
speed: 405.9 km/sec
density: 7.7 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2046 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: C3 2000 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 2000 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2050 UT "
+ rising again (!?) ... (or temporary? ...) :
" Solar wind
speed: 435.0 km/sec
density: 8.9 protons/cm3
more data: ACE, DSCOVR
Updated: Today at 2056 UT
X-ray Solar Flares
6-hr max: C3 2000 UT Oct31
24-hr: C3 2000 UT Oct31
explanation | more data
Updated: Today at: 2100 UT "
...
2) Latest description from spaceweather.com (and kind of apologetic ...):
" WEAK CME IMPACT AND GEOMAGNETIC STORM: A CME hit Earth's magnetic field on Oct. 31st at ~10:00 UT. The impact was weak--a far cry from the "big hit" we expected--and it sparked an equally weak G1-class geomagnetic storm.
In Alberta, Canada, photographer Harlan Thomas stayed up all night waiting for the predicted strong geomagnetic storm. Instead, he caught this lesser display just before sunrise over icy Dewitt Pond:
"It was a short-lived event," says Thomas. "The auroras were active and battled the twilight until about 45 minutes before the sun came up."
In summary, the Halloween Storm of 2021 was more trick than treat. What happened? It's possible that the bulk of the Oct. 28th CME simply missed our planet. The source of the CME, sunspot AR2887, is located in the sun's southern hemisphere. When it exploded 3 days ago, much of the debris flew south of the sun-Earth line. Computer models suggesting a direct hit apparently gave too little weight to the CME's assymetry.
Hey, it happens! Space weather forecasting is a probabilistic activity beset by the unknowns of storms that get started 93 million miles away from Earth and glide for days invisibly through the near vacuum of interplanetary space before they spring upon us with little warning. May be next time... "
Last edited: