What are the Key Factors for Victory in the 2008 Presidential Election?

  • News
  • Thread starter Evo
  • Start date
In summary, the key factors for victory in the 2008 Presidential Election were the candidates' ability to connect with voters, the state of the economy and the overall political climate, and the use of effective campaign strategies. Barack Obama's strong message of hope and change resonated with many Americans, while John McCain struggled to distance himself from the unpopular incumbent president, George W. Bush. The economic crisis of 2008 also played a significant role, with many voters looking for a candidate who could offer solutions to the financial struggles facing the country. Additionally, Obama's effective use of social media and grassroots organizing helped him secure a strong base of support and ultimately win the election.

Who will win the General Election?

  • Obama by over 15 Electoral Votes

    Votes: 16 50.0%
  • Obama by under 15 Electoral Votes

    Votes: 6 18.8%
  • McCain by over 15 Electoral Votes

    Votes: 4 12.5%
  • McCain by under 15 Electoral Votes

    Votes: 6 18.8%

  • Total voters
    32
  • #351
Code:
in place of the ideologically popular choices that the current administration has employed.
' popular' may not be the most accurate word here.

'rammed down the throats' may work as a substitute. :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #352
Senate sends big spending bill to Bush to sign
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080927/ap_on_go_co/congress_spending
WASHINGTON - Automakers gained $25 billion in taxpayer-subsidized loans and oil companies won elimination of a long-standing ban on drilling off the Atlantic and Pacific coasts as the Senate passed a sprawling spending bill Saturday.

The 78-12 vote sent the $634 billion measure to President Bush, who was expected to sign it even though it spends more money and contains more pet projects than he would have liked.

The measure is needed to keep the government operating beyond the current budget year, which ends Tuesday. As a result, the legislation is one of the few bills this election year that simply must pass. Bush's signature would mean Congress could avoid a lame-duck session after the Nov. 4 election.

White House spokesman Tony Fratto said the bill "stands as a reminder of the failure of the Democratic Congress to fund the government in regular order." But, he said, it "puts the United States one step closer to ending our dependence on foreign sources of energy" by lifting the offshore drilling ban and opening up huge reserves of oil shale in the West.

The Pentagon is in line for a record budget. In addition to $70 billion approved this summer for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, the Defense Department would receive $488 billion, a 6 percent increase. The spending bill also offers aid to victims of flooding in the Midwest and recent hurricanes across the Gulf Coast.

Such a huge bill usually would dominate the end-of-session agenda on Capitol Hill. But it went below the radar screen because attention focused on the congressional bailout of Wall Street.
. . . .

Taxpayers for Common Sense, a watchdog group, discovered 2,322 pet projects totaling $6.6 billion. That included 2,025 in the defense portion alone that cost a total of $4.9 billion. Critics of such "earmarks" promise to scrutinize them in coming weeks and months for links to lobbyists and campaign contributions.

Earmarks dot omnibus spending bill
http://www.upi.com/Top_News/2008/09/26/Earmarks_dot_omnibus_spending_bill/UPI-41981222434637/

Taxpayers for Common Sense said the senator who sought the most pet projects was Alaska Republican Ted Stevens -- on trial for allegedly failing to disclose more than $250,000 in gifts and home renovations. Stevens requested 39 projects totaling $238.5 million, The New York Times reported yesterday.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #353
Last edited:
  • #354
Astronuc said:
I agree with this assessment. When McCain talks about tax credits for health insurance, he doesn't seem to get it that those who can't afford health insurance also don't pay much in the way of taxes - because their incomes are too low.

There are about 47 million Americans without health insurance (I wonder if that includes illegal aliens and migrant workers).
http://www.nchc.org/facts/coverage.shtml
Yes that figure includes: illegal aliens, those that qualify for medicaid but never sign up, twenty somethings that can easily afford coverage but still choose not to buy, and those that that don't qualify for government help but still can't afford insurance (pre-existing/chronic).

Numbers on the breakdown:
https://www.physicsforums.com/showpost.php?p=1636972&postcount=37
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #355
mheslep, do you currently have employer healthcare? Have you ever had to try to get health care insurance in the private market? I have. What experience do you have with getting private health insurance? Do you have a pre-exisiting health condition that prevents you from getting private health insurance (my mother does) and I have had to deal with that financially. Do you understand the difference between group health coverage (relatively inexpenseve) and non-group health coverage (very expensive) offers fewer choices, less coverage, higher deductibles, more out of pocket expenses, no cap on catastrophic medical expenses, and poorer health care options.

I can tell you that McCain's plan is disastrous for the average American.
 
  • #356
Evo said:
mheslep, do you currently have employer healthcare?
Yes, heavy PPO family plan w/ dependents. ~$20k/yr, employer pays ~60%.
Have you ever had to try to get health care insurance in the private market. I have. What experience do you have with getting private health insurance?
Yes. Years ago was self employed, used a small business group plan, and more recently I stay on top of quotes for high deductible HSAs. Same exact plan, same insurer as my PPO above but ~half the cost including the cost of the deductible. Just ran it again: $2870/yr + $7500 deductible = $10370, same exact coverage/insurer. As you can see, the HSA plan is much preferable IF I could get my employer to pay me the benefit directly as salary rather than as health care. This point comes up often in my company as there are many that have prior experience as self-employed.
https://www.ehealthinsurance.com/ehi/individual-health-insurance.fs
Do you have a pre-exisiting health condition that prevents you from getting private health insurance (my mother does) and I have had to deal with that financially.
Well I hope your mother gets all the care she needs. If your mother is retired, I assume we're not talking about employer based plans in this case? If so, how is that relevant to McCain's plan and this discussion? Doesn't Medicare help out?

...

I can tell you that McCain's plan is disastrous for the average American
Yes I know, he's 'insane', 'clueless', etc.
 
  • #357
Astronuc said:
I could see 55% of the popular vote for Obama and 45% for McCain, but I would not be surprised if it went 60/40 Obama/McCain.
I would be shocked if Obama won by 10%. And if nothing disastrous happens over the next month, I will not believe the numbers if they say Obama won by 20%.
 
  • #358
Gokul43201 said:
I would be shocked if Obama won by 10%. And if nothing disastrous happens over the next month, I will not believe the numbers if they say Obama won by 20%.

I'm looking for a 60/40 split in the electoral map. 10% in the popular vote wouldn't surprise me at all, but I'm not counting on it.
 
  • #359
Bush binges; Obama or McCain will pay
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0908/14027.html

The focus right now – and probably for many months to come – is the bailout binge aimed at saving our financial system. All told, the government will likely put more than $1 trillion on the line (with hope the money will be recouped down the road).

Then there are the two wars, in Iraq and Afghanistan. The combined cost is fast approaching $1 trillion, too – and both will eat up the time and budgets of the next president.

Then there is also the prescription drug benefit Bush added to Medicare. It carries a projected price tag of nearly $700 billion over ten years and serves as a powerful reminder of how big – untenably big, many experts say – our entitlement programs have grown.

None of that spending was cooked into the federal budget when Bush took office eight years ago, leaving a budgetary hole almost too deep to comprehend. It will tie the hands of President McCain or President Obama in ways neither candidate has reckoned with yet on the campaign trail.

It’s really a federal fiscal catastrophe in coming years,” says Chris Edwards of the Cato Institute, a libertarian-oriented think tank. “With all this stuff coming up now, it’s massive, big decisions the next president is going to have to make.”
. . .
How can you cut taxes when the government is so deep in the red? The budget deficit is projected to top $400 billion – and that was before the bailout.

How can you expand health care coverage when the country is broke? The federal debt is now expected to top $11 trillion by 2010.

How can you focus on “earmarks” and “waste” when everyone knows they make up a meaningless fraction of the federal budget?

. . . .
What about the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq - another $500 billion during the next 4 years?
 
  • #360
Interesting piece discussing who the real John McCain is.
http://www.salon.com/books/review/2008/09/29/mccain/index.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #361
Index of the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008

http://www.house.gov/apps/list/press/financialsvcs_dem/press092808.shtml
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #362
SEC. 122. INCREASE IN STATUTORY LIMIT ON THE PUBLIC
4 DEBT.
5 Subsection (b) of section 3101 of title 31, United
6 States Code, is amended by striking out the dollar limita7
tion contained in such subsection and inserting
8 ‘‘$11,315,000,000,000’’.

wow. Pretty soon it adds up to real money.
 
  • #363
Alfi said:
wow. Pretty soon it adds up to real money.
So that's where they snuck that in. I guess that covers the $700 billion and another $400+ billion deficit for FY2009.

I wonder if they hope that no one actually reads the entire document or if they do, they don't notice the details.
 
  • #364
Interesting, almost everyone (except the young Earth creationist) in my office is voting for Obama, and these people are from Missouri and Kansas. Even my boss, who is Hispanic, is voting for Obama. He even has a personally autographed photo of Obama in his office. All of these people are highly religious, they grab you and start praying over you in the office, one is a minister. They *LOVE* Obama. Doesn't this go against the grain of who is supposed to be pro-Obama? Maybe there is more support for Obama than is reflected in the polls. In my office alone there are over 100 people, so I would say that it is a pretty good sampling.
 
  • #365
Evo said:
Interesting, almost everyone (except the young Earth creationist) in my office is voting for Obama, and these people are from Missouri and Kansas. Even my boss, who is Hispanic, is voting for Obama. He even has a personally autographed photo of Obama in his office. All of these people are highly religious, they grab you and start praying over you in the office, one is a minister. They *LOVE* Obama. Doesn't this go against the grain of who is supposed to be pro-Obama? Maybe there is more support for Obama than is reflected in the polls. In my office alone there are over 100 people, so I would say that it is a pretty good sampling.

It's not that surprising really. Obama is a religious man after all. Though he does not wear it on his sleeves or take policy positions that pander to the far right faith agendas. It's not exactly like he is a heathen that Catholics or Baptists can't relate to.
 
  • #366
LowlyPion said:
It's not that surprising really. Obama is a religious man after all. Though he does not wear it on his sleeves or take policy positions that pander to the far right faith agendas. It's not exactly like he is a heathen that Catholics or Baptists can't relate to.
It's funnier that these people think Palin is crazy. They are the people she is supposed to attract.
 
Last edited:
  • #367
It's been reported that Palin was asked to name an important Supreme Court ruling besides Roe v. Wade and she couldn't come up with one.

Apparently it will air tomorrow in a Katy Couric interview excerpt.

Yikes.

Of course besides Roe v. Wade others like Brown V Board, or Miranda, or US v Nixon, or Bush v. Gore, Dred Scott have had little to do with the course of US affairs and the basis of our laws. Heck who needs to know stuff like that anyway? It's only our HISTORY.
 
  • #368
Evo said:
It's funnier that these people think Palin is crazy.

You can't say they aren't paying attention then.
 
  • #369
I just saw this. It's a clip of how a Faux News reporter can't even spin the results of a live poll properly. Apparently a Fox reporter decided to poll some customers in a small town PA diner to see who they'll vote for:

KTkqosRiyYo[/youtube] Hilarious.
 
  • #370


The swingman cometh?

Electoral maps (Obama/McCain):
Code:
                     AGGREGATES OF CURRENT POLLS                 |     PROJECTIONS
                                                                 |
Date      RCP1     RCP2     CNN   Elec-Vote  USAtlas-A  Pollster | Elec-Proj  USAtlas-P   
                                                                      
06/21   238/163  289/249  211/194  317/194    271/191            |  349/189    298/240
06/26   238/163  317/221  211/194  317/194    288/180            |  338/200    298/240 
07/01   238/163  304/234  231/194  317/221    268/180            |  338/200    293/245 
07/06   238/163  304/234  231/194  320/218    268/177            |  338/200    293/245
07/11   238/163  304/234  231/194  320/215    268/188            |  306/232    293/245
07/16   255/163  304/234  231/194  320/204    268/177            |  311/227    293/245
07/21   255/163  322/216  231/194  312/199    268/172   293/214  |  298/240    293/245
07/26   238/163  322/216  221/189  292/195    264/175   284/147  |  338/200    298/240
08/11   238/163  322/216  221/189  289/236    264/202   284/157  |  298/240    293/245
08/21   228/174  264/274  221/189  264/261    264/210   260/191  |  264/274    293/245
08/26   228/174  273/265  221/189  273/252    259/210   260/176  |  273/265    293/245
09/06   238/174  273/265  243/189  301/224    259/194   260/179  |  278/260    293/245                                                                           
09/16   207/227  286/252  233/189  247/257    216/246   243/219  |  273/265    273/265
09/26   228/163  286/252  240/200  286/252    264/185   229/174  |  273/265    273/265
10/01   249/163  348/190  250/189  286/190    264/185   250/174  |  273/265    273/265
 
Last edited:
  • #371
Defennder said:
Apparently a Fox reporter decided to poll some customers in a small town PA diner to see who they'll vote for:
That's not just any "small town". That was Scranton, PA - home to Hillary and Biden.
 
  • #372
Defennder said:
I just saw this. It's a clip of how a Faux News reporter can't even spin the results of a live poll properly. Apparently a Fox reporter decided to poll some customers in a small town PA diner to see who they'll vote for:

KTkqosRiyYo[/youtube] Hilarious....voters and viewers they apparently appeal to.
 
  • #373


Market Update:
Code:
               INTRADE       IOWA ELECTRONIC MARKET

           Obama    McCain      Dem     Rep
June 26    $64.1    $32.4      0.622   0.378
July 11    $65.0    $31.2      0.643   0.358
July 26    $63.2    $32.2      0.688   0.355
Aug  11    $59.2    $37.2      0.621   0.377
Oct 01     $64.8    $34.6      0.651   0.322
 
  • #374


Your market update doesn't include the period for early September when McCain got his post convention bump. I'd like to know what the numbers were then.
 
  • #375
LowlyPion said:
Well all the Fox people behind the camera were raising their hands.

I think to work at Fox you have to be certified as dummie. Even Hannity's token liberal foil Coombs, is a dummie because Hannity can't compete with anything warmer than a corpse.

This is apparently why they like McCain (at the bottom of the Naval Academy class), and Palin a shallow thinker par excellance that just reads what's put in front of her. These are the kinds of voters and viewers they apparently appeal to.
If I recall correctly, Fox preferred Giuliani in the GOP primaries. Don't think they had a good opinion of McCain then.
 
  • #376
Obama was brilliant today.

Perfectly staged address, standing from his seat in the Senate, he could have been Jimmy Stewart, delivering his speech in support of the Senate version to economic recovery.

In one brilliant image he makes all this McCain nonsense about being in the Arena into desperate rhetoric of a failing campaign. McCain can soon start making his retirement plans.

Maybe he and Bush can go on a fishing trip?
(I personally wouldn't recommend going hunting with ol' 2nd Amendment Chaney, however.)
 
Last edited:
  • #377


Defennder said:
Your market update doesn't include the period for early September when McCain got his post convention bump. I'd like to know what the numbers were then.
Updated upon request - the bump you are looking for is visible in the Sep 11 numbers.

Market Update:
Code:
               INTRADE       IOWA ELECTRONIC MARKET

           Obama    McCain      Dem     Rep
Jun 26     $64.1    $32.4      0.622   0.378
Jul 11     $65.0    $31.2      0.643   0.358
Jul 26     $63.2    $32.2      0.688   0.355
Aug 11     $59.9    $37.2      0.621   0.377
Aug 21     $59.0    $38.7      0.607   0.394
Sep 01     $61.1    $39.2      0.602   0.395
Sep 11     $49.0    $49.9      0.540   0.462
Sep 21     $51.3    $47.7      0.601   0.392
Oct 01     $64.8    $34.6      0.651   0.322

Note: day-to-day fluctuations are about $1 in the Intrade markets and about 0.01 points in the IEM.
 
  • #378
Des Moines Straight Talk Express:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoHSLrnjdCI
 
  • #379
LowlyPion said:
Des Moines Straight Talk Express:

The guy looks like he's seething...he looks like he's ready to blow up! No way McCain has the temperment needed to be President. No way, no how...
 
  • #380
Woohoo! CNN shows Obama leading in both Ohio and Florida. Yipppeeee!

They also show Obama gaining ground with women, and in particular married women. He is also leading in Florida with people over 50 year of age. THAT is huge! Finally, he now has a higher favorability rating than McCain, which is a first.
 
Last edited:
  • #381
lisab said:
The guy looks like he's seething...he looks like he's ready to blow up! No way McCain has the temperment needed to be President. No way, no how...

What I find disturbing is his stubborn clinging to the idea that Obama had any intent to distribute condoms to kindergartners. The bill he has signed referred to "age appropriate" education. I think the thing that Conservatives are really not wanting to discuss is that the bill mentioned discussion of same sex heads of households, wanting instead I suppose to instill ignorance among school children that are already in many cases witness to such arrangements, either in their families or their classmates. Just another thing that encourages divisiveness in society.
 
  • #382
Ivan Seeking said:
Finally, he now has a higher favorability rating than McCain, which is a first.
That's not true. McCain held a higher favorability rating than Obama only for a brief period of a week or two following the Palin announcement. Before that (since at least as long ago as June), as well as over this last week, Obama has had McCain beat, in terms of favorability.

See, for instance: http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/2008/president/favorable.html
 
  • #383
Hmmm, are you sure? I thought McCain was always leading in this category... [ah, didn't see the link]

Holding my breath: Based on the current map, Florida alone puts Obama over the top. And I saw one poll that gives Obama an additional 4 point spread [in Florida] when third-party candidates are included.
 
Last edited:
  • #384
Ivan Seeking said:
Woohoo! CNN shows Obama leading in both Ohio and Florida. Yipppeeee!

They also show Obama gaining ground with women, and in particular married women. He is also leading in Florida with people over 50 year of age. THAT is huge! Finally, he now has a higher favorability rating than McCain, which is a first.
The age thing is pretty big.

The most amazing thing in the polls has been Virginia and North Carolina being so close while Obama hasn't been able to seal the deal in Michigan and Ohio. This has a lot to do with the age gap in voter preference. States from the rust belt with declining populations are older - the young people move somewhere with a better future. States with a growing economy attract more young people, so states like Colorado, Arizona, New Mexico, Virginia aren't as solidly Republican as they used to.

If Obama breaks that age gap, then he can probably seal up the election. Depending on young voters is a risky way to go since they aren't as dependable in showing up at the voting booth.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top